Clinical Description
Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) deletion syndromes predominantly comprise three overlapping phenotypes that are usually simplex (i.e., a single occurrence in a family), but rarely may be observed in different members of the same family or may evolve from one clinical syndrome to another in a given individual over time. The three classic phenotypes caused by mtDNA deletions are Kearns-Sayre syndrome (KSS), Pearson syndrome, and progressive external ophthalmoplegia (PEO). Rarely, Leigh syndrome can be a manifestation of a mtDNA deletion.
"KSS spectrum" has been proposed as a phenotypic category that includes classic KSS and PEO with multisystem involvement. A retrospective analysis of an Italian cohort of 253 individuals with a single mtDNA deletion showed 6.6% had classic KSS, 31.6% met criteria for KSS spectrum, 64.5% had PEO, and 2.6% had Pearson syndrome. Likewise, in a retrospective review of the natural history of 34 children with a single large-scale mtDNA deletion (SLSMD) in the United Kingdom, the most common initial presentation was isolated ptosis (47%). 10/34 had KSS, 3/34 had PEO, 7/34 had PEO-plus ("KSS spectrum"), and 11/34 had Pearson syndrome. Three individuals did not conform to a specific mitochondrial phenotype [Broomfield et al 2015].
Kearns-Sayre Syndrome (KSS)
KSS is a multisystem disorder defined by a clinical triad consisting of onset before age 20 years, pigmentary retinopathy (sometimes referred to as "retinitis pigmentosa"), and progressive external ophthalmoplegia (PEO), plus at least one of the following: cardiac conduction defects leading to complete heart block, cerebellar ataxia, and/or elevated CSF protein. KSS predominantly affects the central nervous system, skeletal muscle, and heart. Onset is usually in childhood, with ptosis, ophthalmoplegia, or both. Exercise intolerance and impaired night vision (nyctalopia) may be early symptoms. Dysphagia caused by oropharyngeal weakness and/or incomplete opening of the upper esophageal sphincter (cricopharyngeal achalasia) is common. KSS usually progresses to death in young adulthood.
Central nervous system involvement manifests as cerebellar ataxia, impaired intellect (intellectual disability, dementia, or both), and sensorineural hearing loss. Compared to other mitochondrial encephalomyopathies (e.g., MELAS, MERRF, and NARP), KSS is notable for the extreme rarity of epilepsy. Metabolic strokes are also rare, although the Leigh syndrome overlap phenotype may occur. In a recent retrospective analysis of metabolic stroke, one individual had a SLSMD and received intravenous arginine therapy for non-focal (but worsening over baseline) ophthalmoplegia and ataxia together with new onset of atonic episodes. After intravenous arginine administration, partial improvement was seen in atonic episodes. MRI revealed bilateral symmetric basal ganglia and white matter lesions consistent with Leigh syndrome [Ganetzky & Falk 2018]. Brain MRI may yield findings of a leukoencephalopathy, Leigh syndrome, and/or cerebral and cerebellar atrophy [Friedman et al 2010, Alves et al 2018]. A secondary cerebral folate deficiency has been reported in KSS, where supplementation with folinic acid can be beneficial [Quijada-Fraile et al 2014] and may reverse white matter abnormalities seen on imaging with corresponding subjective improvement in coordination.
Skeletal muscle involvement manifests as PEO including ptosis, oropharyngeal and esophageal dysfunction, exercise intolerance, fatigue, and limb muscle weakness (proximal > distal). The defect of extraocular movement is usually symmetric but may cause blurred or double vision. Ptosis is usually asymmetric and exacerbated by fatigue.
Heart involvement is most commonly characterized by conduction block, which can be progressive and lead to complete heart block. Cardiomyopathy, less commonly than cardiac conduction block, has been reported in several individuals. Cardiac MRI is an emerging tool used to detect subclinical cardiac involvement [Kabunga et al 2015].
Endocrinopathies are common in KSS and include diabetes mellitus, exocrine pancreatic enzyme deficiencies, hypoparathyroidism, growth hormone deficiency, adrenal insufficiency, and irregular menses. Short stature may be the result of growth hormone deficiency and/or failure to thrive. Individuals may present with extreme hypocalcemia and tetany due to hypoparathyroidism [Katsanos et al 2001]. Diabetes mellitus may be caused by both insulin deficiency and insulin resistance, and is associated with higher hemoglobin A1c, lower BMI, lower rates of diabetic ketoacidosis, higher associated neuropathy and nephropathy rates, and less diabetic ophthalmologic involvement.
Renal tubular acidosis occurs in individuals with KSS and may be the presenting feature [Eviatar et al 1990]. The kidney is the most frequently affected organ over the course of disease, with tubular or glomerular dysfunction occurring in 85% (17/20) [Broomfield et al 2015]. Impaired renal function can be determined by decreased glomerular filtration rate or abnormal elevation of urinary tubulopathy markers such as retinol binding protein [Bernard et al 1987] or N-acetyl-3-glucosaminidase [Vaidya et al 2008] – potentially useful screening biomarkers in presymptomatic individuals [Herget-Rosenthal et al 2004].
Pigmentary retinopathy of KSS affects low-light vision more prominently than visual acuity, leading affected individuals to report impaired night vision (nyctalopia). Funduscopy reveals an atypical "salt and pepper" retinopathy. Electroretinogram often reveals rod-cone retinal dystrophy. Visual field testing reveals normal visual fields. Peripheral vision may be compromised by ptosis. Vision generally deteriorates insidiously, making age at onset difficult to discern (see Table 2).
Table 2.
Signs and Symptoms in 86 Individuals with Kearns-Sayre Syndrome
View in own window
Sign or Symptom | Present/Evaluated | Percentage |
---|
Onset age <20 yrs | 86/86 | 100% |
Pigmentary retinopathy | 86/86 | 100% |
PEO | 86/86 | 100% |
Cerebellar syndrome | 53/63 | 84% |
Limb weakness | 61/65 | 94% |
Sensorineural hearing loss | 33/34 | 97% |
Impaired intellect | 25/29 | 86% |
Diabetes mellitus | 11/86 | 13% |
Seizures | 2/86 | 2% |
Pearson Syndrome
Pearson syndrome is a mtDNA deletion syndrome that manifests clinically with bone marrow failure, severe transfusion-dependent sideroblastic anemia, and variable exocrine pancreatic insufficiency. Pearson syndrome features are variable and progressive. Anemia typically appears in the first year of life and may be accompanied by pancytopenia and multisystem involvement including failure to thrive, hypotonia, and metabolic derangements including lactic acidosis. Additional features may include hydrops fetalis, hepatic involvement with elevated transaminases and steatosis, microcephaly, renal Fanconi syndrome, endocrinopathies (growth hormone deficiency, hypothyroidism, hypoparathyroidism, diabetes mellitus, and adrenal insufficiency), splenic atrophy, impaired cardiac function, refractory diarrhea, and acute metabolic decompensations during intercurrent illness. Death may occur in early infancy or childhood due to metabolic decompensation, liver failure, or sepsis due to neutropenia. Survival and spontaneous recovery from bone marrow dysfunction after several years is possible, with a transition to clinical manifestations of KSS. In an Italian cohort of 11 individuals with Pearson syndrome, 64% developed neurologic sequelae and KSS [Manea et al 2009, Morel et al 2009, Williams et al 2012, Crippa et al 2015, Farruggia et al 2016].
Sideroblastic anemia is defined by the presence of anemia and ringed sideroblasts in the bone marrow. Ringed sideroblasts are normoblasts (precursors to mature red blood cells) with excessive deposits of iron in mitochondria and are detected by iron stains of bone marrow. The original report of Pearson syndrome included severe-onset transfusion-dependent macrocytic, sideroblastic anemia with a variable degree of neutropenia and thrombocytopenia (pancytopenia), normocellular bone marrow (although hypocellularity may occur), striking vacuolization of the hematopoietic progenitor cells, hemosiderosis, and ringed sideroblasts [Pearson et al 1979].
Exocrine pancreatic dysfunction due to pancreatic fibrosis is manifest clinically by failure to thrive, malabsorption, chronic diarrhea, and excessive fat excretion in the stools (steatorrhea), which can be documented qualitatively by Sudan staining of the feces or quantitatively by measuring fecal fat. The gold standard is the secretin stimulation test, which requires placing a catheter in the duodenum and is technically difficult to perform in infants. Exocrine pancreatic dysfunction is a variable feature that is not seen in up to 73% of individuals with Pearson syndrome [Farruggia et al 2016].
Chronic Progressive External Ophthalmoplegia (PEO)
CPEO is characterized by ptosis and extraocular muscle paralysis (ophthalmoplegia) that is progressive over time. CPEO, or CPEO-plus, variably also includes severe oropharyngeal and proximal limb weakness. The disorder is compatible with a normal life span.
Leigh Syndrome
Leigh syndrome typically begins in infancy and is characterized by psychomotor regression or delay with disease manifestations involving the brain stem, basal ganglia, or both.
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
In some reported cohorts, disease progression correlates with mtDNA heteroplasmy levels as well as mtDNA deletion size and location [Grady et al 2014]. Several reports in the literature have attempted to predict disease severity, most recently in a group of 87 individuals with SLSMD in the Newcastle (UK) mitochondrial disease cohort, of whom nine had classic KSS and 54 had CPEO or "CPEO-plus myopathy." A meta-analysis of this and prior published cohorts compared the degree of COX-negative fibers on muscle biopsy (as a marker of biochemical severity), age of clinical disease onset, and disease burden (as measured by the Newcastle Mitochondrial Disease Adult Scale[NMDAS]) with the mtDNA deletion location, size, and heteroplasmy level. In both their own cohort and the larger meta-analysis, age of disease onset directly correlated with deletion size, location (e.g., including complex III and IV subunit genes MT-CYB and MT-COX), and heteroplasmy levels, factors that were significant predictors of disease progression as measured by NMDAS scores. A web tool is available for prognosis and predicted disease progression based on these factors (research.ncl.ac.uk/mitoresearch) [Grady et al 2014].
In contrast, other cohorts of individuals with SLSMD did not show a correlation between age and deletion size or inclusion of MT-CYB within the deletion.
For all mtDNA pathogenic variants, clinical expressivity depends on three factors:
Tissue vulnerability thresholds likely do not vary substantially among affected individuals, whereas variable proportions of the mtDNA deletion and their tissue distribution may account for the wide spectrum of clinical findings that may occur in individuals with KSS.
The fact that mtDNA deletions are present in all tissues in individuals with KSS, are predominantly present in hematopoietic cells of individuals with Pearson syndrome, and are confined to skeletal muscle in PEO explains different clinical phenotypes. The gradual decrease in mtDNA deletions in rapidly dividing blood cells and their gradual increase in postmitotic tissues is an example of mitotic segregation, and explains how infants with Pearson syndrome may develop KSS later in life.
Nomenclature
The general terms for the neuromuscular disorders include "progressive external ophthalmoplegia (PEO)" and "chronic progressive external ophthalmoplegia (CPEO)."
The multisystemic form of CPEO is called Kearns-Sayre syndrome (KSS). In the past, KSS was also referred to as "ophthalmoplegia-plus" (CPEO plus), a term now used to describe individuals who have more than isolated myopathy but do not fulfill classic clinical criteria for KSS. "KSS spectrum" and "CPEO-plus" are both used to indicate when an individual's clinical presentation is less severe than typical of classic KSS but includes multisystem symptoms beyond CPEO. KSS requires onset before age 20 years, although some investigators have reported individuals with CPEO-plus and a disease onset below age 20 years.
For Pearson syndrome, the term "Pearson marrow pancreas syndrome" is a synonym. The term "sideroblastic anemia and exocrine pancreatic dysfunction" is not currently used.
Leigh syndrome has also been described as "subacute necrotizing encephalomyelopathy."