The aim of targeted therapies is to restore a functional immune system, which is essential to preventing the life-threatening manifestations of ADA-SCID. This requires correcting the ADA deficiency either system-wide or selectively in lymphoid cells. At present, the three options for the specific treatment of ADA-SCID are presented in Table 4. Selection of the initial therapy depends on factors such as the age and clinical status of the individual, the expectations and desires of the parents, the availability of the therapy, and the experience and expertise of the treating physicians.
Enzyme Replacement Therapy (ERT) with PEGylated ADA
Between 1990 and 2019, ERT for ADA-SCID was performed with Adagen® (pegademase bovine), consisting of bovine ADA isolated from cow intestine and modified ("PEGylated") by attachment of multiple strands of 5 kDa monomethoxypolyethylene glycol (mPEG). In January 2019, Adagen® was replaced by Revcovi® (elapegademase-lvlr), which is similar but prepared with recombinant bovine ADA.
The US clinical trial that supported FDA approval of Revcovi® showed that it was safe and maintained biochemical detoxification and lymphocyte counts in six adults who had previously been treated for an average of 20 years with Adagen® [Dorsey et al 2023]. To date, there is little published information about the use of Revcovi® as initial therapy in newly diagnosed individuals with ADA-SCID. However, when used according to the package insert, Revcovi® was reported to be well tolerated and effective in the management of six infants, five of whom had been identified by newborn screening [Murguia-Favela et al 2023]. The general recommendations of Kohn et al [2019] regarding ERT appear to apply to Revcovi® when used according to the Revcovi® package insert.
Prior to initiation of ERT, baseline levels of ADA (i.e., ADA1) catalytic activity and total deoxyadenosine nucleotides (dAXP) in red blood cells should be determined. (Note: Prior to replacement therapy with PEGylated ADA, ADA catalytic activity in plasma is negligible in individuals with ADA-SCID as well as in controls).
The starting dose of Revcovi® recommended in the package insert is 0.4 mg/kg (based on ideal body weight) divided into two intramuscular injections of 0.2 mg/kg per week. Following an intramuscular injection, Revcovi® is absorbed and circulates in plasma but does not enter cells. At the recommended dose of Revcovi®, ADA catalytic activity in plasma increases approximately 100-fold, a level at which all the deoxyadenosine (dAdo) produced daily from DNA breakdown is deaminated. As a result, dAdo does not enter the cells of the ADA-deficient individual and, thus, does not undergo phosphorylation to dAXP, which prevents expansion of the intracellular pool of dAXP, the major metabolic cause of the profound lymphopenia present in neonates with ADA-SCID.
Biochemical monitoring of ERT, beginning about two weeks after the first dose of Revcovi®, involves measuring (1) trough (i.e., pre-injection) level of ADA catalytic activity in plasma, which is due entirely to Revcovi®, and (2) dAXP levels in red blood cells. These measurements should be repeated at two- to four-week intervals. While the dAXP levels in red blood cells will begin to decline with the initiation of ERT, it usually requires six to eight weeks for dAXP to fully disappear. Thereafter, sustained normalization of dAXP levels in red blood cells is a useful marker of metabolic correction, and frequency of monitoring can be reduced at the provider's discretion.
It is recommended that ERT be continued for a minimum of 12 to 24 weeks until immune reconstitution is achieved. If lymphocyte counts and in vitro function are satisfactory and clinical status is stable, the dose of Revcovi® may then be consolidated and given once weekly in order to maintain (1) trough (pre-injection) ADA catalytic activity in plasma above 30 mmol/hr/L, and (2) dAXP level in packed red blood cells below 0.02 mmol/L. Although maintaining these two conditions is necessary, in some individuals it may not be sufficient to sustain protective immune function.
In addition to permitting immune reconstitution, ERT has been associated with resolution of hepatocellular abnormalities, pulmonary alveolar proteinosis, and skeletal dysplasia; however, to date this has not been studied systematically. Additionally, in some individuals the neurologic/behavioral abnormalities associated with ADA deficiency have improved; however, it is uncertain if ERT can reverse or prevent these complications.
ERT should be provided continuously until an affected individual is able to undergo definitive therapy with HSCT or HSC-GT, ideally within two years of diagnosis. Of note, the optimal time to discontinue ERT before HSCT or HSC-GT has not been systematically studied; however, in recent years, ERT has been discontinued at the time of HSCT or up to a month after HSCT or HSC-GT.
Between 1990 and 2019, when Revcovi® (PEGylated recombinant bovine ADA) became available, ERT for ADA deficiency was performed with Adagen® (PEGylated purified bovine ADA). Adagen® was used as a long-term therapy in individuals who lacked a suitable HSC donor or were not considered to be candidates for HSCT, or when HSC-GT was unavailable. Some individuals received ERT with Adagen® and did well clinically for up to three decades. However, a gradual decline in lymphocyte counts and immune function occurred in a number of individuals treated with Adagen® for more than five to eight years, resulting in increased frequency of infection and risk of malignancy (lymphoma, hepatic) [Kohn et al 2019]. Because of this experience with Adagen®, long-term maintenance therapy with Revcovi® is not recommended.
Allogeneic Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation (HSCT)
Bone marrow / stem cell transplantation from an HLA-identical healthy sib is the method of choice for treating all forms of SCID. Matched familial donors also have good clinical outcomes.
Once the diagnosis of ADA-SCID is verified, HLA (human leukocyte antigen) typing of the affected individual, sibs, and parents should be performed.
HSCT can be performed without cytoreductive conditioning of the affected individual and without depletion of donor T cells.
Results vary among transplant centers, but the procedure is curative in 70% or more of affected individuals.
The main risks are graft-vs-host disease and delayed or incomplete recovery of humoral immune function that requires continued immunoglobulin replacement therapy.
Bone marrow / stem cell transplant from a "non-ideal" donor can be considered for the majority of individuals with ADA-SCID who lack an HLA-identical related donor. However, this has the least favorable clinical outcomes regarding sustained immunity and survival [Gaspar et al 2009, Gaspar 2010, Candotti et al 2012, Baffelli et al 2015].
Among alternative donors, HLA-matched unrelated donors historically have provided better outcomes than haploidentical HSCT.
Adult bone marrow or peripheral blood stem cells are preferred over umbilical cord blood.
Donor-derived T cells are depleted to minimize the risk of graft-vs-host disease.
Pre-transplant cytoreductive "conditioning" of the individual with ADA-SCID is often performed to prevent graft loss, which occurs with relative frequency in those with ADA-SCID who are not conditioned. The intensity of conditioning is not known.
Note: Some transplant centers do not perform conditioning of the recipient prior to a haploidentical transplant because of the risk of peri-transplant morbidity [
Buckley et al 1999]. However, this latter approach has frequently been associated with a failure to achieve stable engraftment [
Gaspar et al 2009,
Gaspar 2010,
Hassan et al 2012].
Following a T cell-depleted transplant, return of functional T cells requires three to four months. B cell reconstitution is delayed longer or may not be adequately achieved, requiring long-term immunoglobulin replacement therapy.
Sequence-based HLA typing, improved methods for graft engineering, and post-transplant cyclophosphamide for depletion of alloreactive donor T cells may improve outcomes.
Graft failures may occur, resulting in restarting ERT while a second allogeneic HSCT or HSC-GT are being considered.
Note: Universal agreement regarding the best methods for performing partially mismatched HSCT/HSC-GT does not exist [Cancrini et al 2010, Gaspar 2010, Hassan et al 2012]. Therefore, when considering therapeutic options, it is important for parents to obtain specific information about prior experience and long-term results of transplants for ADA-SCID at the center treating their child.