Clinical Description
In all affected individuals reported to date, features of the PNPLA6 disorder are evident in the first two decades of life [Rainier et al 2011, Yoon et al 2013, Deik et al 2014, Synofzik et al 2014a, Hufnagel et al 2015, Kmoch et al 2015, Tarnutzer et al 2015]. The initial findings include one or several of the following features: gait disturbance, visual impairment due to chorioretinal dystrophy or atrophy, anterior hypopituitarism, delayed puberty/primary amenorrhea. Gait disturbance may precede visual impairment or anterior hypopituitarism; or alternatively, gait disturbance may follow visual impairment or hypopituitarism up to 35 years later [Deik et al 2014]. Although the combination of the three most common findings (gait disturbance, visual impairment, and delayed puberty/primary amenorrhea) is highly indicative of an underlying PNPLA6 disorder, no single feature is specific or obligatory.
Some of these features can occur in certain combinations, presenting in partly distinct/partly overlapping clusters on the phenotypic continuum of the PNPLA6 disorders (see Table 2).
Gordon Holmes syndrome (GHS). Cerebellar ataxia, hypogonadotropic hypogonadism, and (to a variable degree) brisk reflexes [
Holmes 1907]
Laurence-Moon syndrome (LMS). Cerebellar ataxia, chorioretinal dystrophy, peripheral neuropathy, spastic paraplegia and congenital or childhood hypopituitarism. One family diagnosed with Laurence-Moon syndrome has been reported to have biallelic pathogenic variants in
PNPLA6 [
Hufnagel et al 2015]. Several other people with the same phenotypic cluster and biallelic pathogenic variants in
PNPLA6 have been reported [
Synofzik et al 2014a] and described as having "spastic Boucher-Neuhäuser syndrome," demonstrating the continuum of
PNPLA6- associated phenotypic clusters.
Spastic paraplegia type 39 (SPG39). Upper motor neuron involvement and peripheral neuropathy, and in some cases reduced cognitive functioning and/or cerebellar ataxia [
Rainier et al 2008]
Severe retinal dystrophy with atrophy associated with autism, reported in one child with biallelic pathogenic variants in
PNPLA6 [
Kmoch et al 2015]. The child had been previously given a diagnosis of Leber congenital amaurosis (LCA). Given the age of the affected individual, it is possible that further features of one of the above clinical diagnoses could develop with time. See
Leber Congenital Amaurosis / Early-Onset Severe Retinal Dystrophy Overview.
Table 2.
PNPLA6 Disorders: Comparison of Phenotypic Clusters by Select Features
View in own window
Phenotypic Feature | PNPLA6 Disorder |
---|
BNS | GHS | OMCS | LMS | SPG39 |
---|
Cerebellar ataxia | + | + | | + | ± |
Peripheral neuropathy | | | | | + |
Spasticity | | + | | + | + |
Cognitive dysfunction | | | | | ± |
Chorioretinal dystrophy | + | | + | + | |
Hypogonadotropic hypogonadism | + | + | | | |
Congenital/childhood anterior hypopituitarism | | | + | + | |
Trichomegaly | | | + | | |
BNS = Boucher-Neuhäuser syndrome; GHS = PNPLA6 Gordon Holmes syndrome; LMS = PNPLA6 Laurence-Moon syndrome; OMCS = Oliver-McFarlane syndrome; SPG39 = spastic paraplegia type 39
Note: The clusters in this table do not constitute distinct phenotypes, as they may overlap in many affected individuals.
Given the limited number of individuals reported to date and the lack of longitudinal studies of affected individuals, a more detailed understanding of the natural history of PNPLA6 disorders remains to be determined.
Gait disturbance is due to ataxia, spasticity (with or without paresis), peripheral neuropathy, or a combination thereof. Progression of the gait disturbance varies: more severely affected individuals lose the ability to walk without aid between ages 25 and 50 years and may become wheelchair dependent at this stage [Rainier et al 2011, Synofzik et al 2014a]; less affected individuals are still able to walk unaided at age 54 years [Synofzik et al 2014a].
Dysarthria and dysphagia are recurrent features in PNPLA6 disorders, evolving throughout the disease course in almost all individuals with cerebellar ataxia. Dysarthria appears to present shortly after onset of gait ataxia, with dysphagia following years later, but detailed natural history studies corroborating this clinical impression are still lacking. Both are likely due to cerebellar dysfunction [Tarnutzer et al 2015]. Likewise, urinary urgency appears to be a recurrent feature at least in individuals with PNPLA6-associated ataxias, but a systematic investigation providing detailed evidence for this clinical impression is likewise still lacking.
Peripheral
neuropathy (if present) is usually of the axonal motor type, including an additional sensory component (sensorimotor neuropathy) reported to date in only three individuals [Author, unpublished observation]. The motor neuropathy can be associated with severe atrophy of distal muscles, in particular the distal leg and intrinsic hand muscles, starting in the late teens [Rainier et al 2011]. Impairment of the sensory tracts (peripheral sensory neurons, dorsal columns) including diminished vibration sense and touch has been reported in different age groups [Rainier et al 2011, Synofzik et al 2014a, Hufnagel et al 2015, Kmoch et al 2015].
Functional impairment due to upper motor neuron involvement varies: while some affected individuals show only increased reflexes or extensor plantar responses, others have severe spastic paraparesis of the lower extremities [Rainier et al 2011, Synofzik et al 2014a, Hufnagel et al 2015]. Electrophysiologic data available are currently insufficient to determine whether corticospinal tract involvement is axonal (with motor evoked potentials showing almost normal central motor conduction times) or demyelinating (with motor evoked potentials showing severely prolonged central motor conduction times).
Progressive visual impairment, which is less frequent than gait disturbances in the PNPLA6 disorders, is typically due to chorioretinal dystrophy. Initially, these findings (which can present in the first few years of life) include nystagmus, choroidal and retinal pigment atrophy, and bitemporal central visual field defects and blind spot enlargement. In adolescence or adulthood visual acuity is often severely reduced (to perception of hand motion) such that some affected individuals meet the criteria for legal blindness [Synofzik et al 2014a, Hufnagel et al 2015, Kmoch et al 2015, Synofzik et al 2015].
Anterior hypopituitarism manifests either in infancy or childhood (micropenis and cryptorchidism in males, and thyroid and growth hormone deficiency) or in adolescence (hypogonadotropic hypogonadism and growth hormone deficiency) [Hufnagel et al 2015].
Congenital hypothyroidism and growth hormone deficiency can result in global developmental delay, severe cognitive impairment, and short stature.
Hypogonadotropic hypogonadism usually becomes manifest during the second decade of life with delayed puberty and lack of secondary sexual characteristics including primary amenorrhea in females, small penis and testes in males, and absent pubic hair and/or breast development.
Cognitive functioning appears to be impaired in many (albeit not all) individuals with a PNPLA6 disorder, including learning disabilities in children [Yoon et al 2013] and deficits in attention, visuospatial abilities, and recall in adults.
The relationship of white matter lesions and cortical and cerebellar degeneration with cognitive disability has not been explored in PNPLA6 disorders; thus, the substrate or network mechanism underlying the cognitive dysfunction is not yet understood.
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
No obvious genotype-phenotype correlation exists, as the same PNPLA6 pathogenic variant can lead to different presentations (e.g., ataxia plus hypogonadism in one individual, and spastic ataxia in another) and to different degrees and rates of progression of manifestation (e.g., loss of ambulation in an individual age 44 years with a 17-year history of ataxia vs full ambulation in an individual age 42 years with a 36-year history of ataxia) [Synofzik et al 2014a]. Correspondingly, manifestations and disease progression differ not only between but also within families.
Nor does the phenotype appear to depend on either the location of the pathogenic variant or the pathogenic variant type (e.g., missense and frameshift variants) [Synofzik et al 2014a, Hufnagel et al 2015, Kmoch et al 2015].