Molecular Pathogenesis
The molecular pathology of Warburg micro syndrome and Martsolf syndrome arises either from the absence of Ras-related protein Rab-18 (RAB18) protein or from its functional absence as a result of dysregulation. Because RAB3GAP1, RAB3GAP2, and TBC1D20 are each essential for the regulation of RAB18, biallelic loss-of-function variants in the genes that encode these proteins lead to clinically indistinguishable phenotypes.
RAB18 encodes a highly conserved member of the RAB subfamily of the RAS superfamily of small GTPases [Handley 2017]. Different RAB protein isoforms function to regulate discrete steps in trafficking between cellular membrane compartments. RAB18 is proposed to have roles in regulation of lipid droplets, lipolysis, and lipogenesis [Martin et al 2005, Ozeki et al 2005, Pulido et al 2011], trafficking between the Golgi and endoplasmic reticulum (ER) [Dejgaard et al 2008, Handley et al 2015], ER structure [Gerondopoulos et al 2014], exocytosis [Vazquez-Martinez et al 2007], and autophagy [Feldmann et al 2017]. The specific cellular deficit(s) that underlie the pathology of Warburg micro syndrome and Martsolf syndrome are not yet known.
In common with other small GTPases, RAB proteins function as "molecular switches." They can bind to GDP or GTP and adopt different conformations according to which nucleotide is bound. These different conformations are in turn associated with altered protein-binding characteristics that affect interactions with regulators and with the mediators of their downstream cellular functions. Switching between GDP- and GTP-bound conformations is tightly regulated by two classes of protein, guanine nucleotide exchange factors (GEFs) and GTPase-activating proteins (GAPs). GEFs mediate the exchange of bound GDP for GTP. GAPs stimulate the intrinsic GTPase activity of the RAB proteins, thereby mediating hydrolysis of bound GTP into GDP.
RAB3GAP1 and RAB3GAP2 each encode essential subunits of a binary complex with GEF activity toward RAB18 [Gerondopoulos et al 2014]. This complex is necessary to mediate GDP-GTP exchange and the associated RAB18 conformational change.
TBC1D20 encodes a RAB-GAP with modest in vitro GAP activity toward RAB18. Several lines of evidence indicate that it functions as a RAB18-GAP physiologically [Haas et al 2007, Handley et al 2015]. The regulation of RAB18 by TBC1D20 opposes that of the RAB3GAP complex, promoting its GDP- rather than the GTP-bound conformation. However, both regulators are required for RAB18 to function appropriately, in a spatiotemporally restricted manner.
RAB3GAP1
Gene structure. The canonic RAB3GAP1 transcript, NM_012233.2, comprises 24 coding exons and encodes a 981-amino acid protein.
An additional in-frame microexon of 21 nucleotides constitutes exon 24 that is incorporated into the 25-exon alternative transcript, NM_001172435; this microexon may be differentially expressed in the brain [Irimia et al 2014]. For a detailed summary of gene and protein information, see Table A, Gene; a summary of transcripts is in Ensemble.
Pathogenic variants. Biallelic pathogenic variants in RAB3GAP1 are the most frequently reported cause of RAB18 deficiency. Pathogenic variants are found throughout the gene and in most cases are likely to compromise gene expression.
Homozygous pathogenic variants were identified in 67 families: 19 were splice site, 18 nonsense, 20 frameshift, six missense, and four intragenic deletions [
Aligianis et al 2005,
Abdel-Salam et al 2007,
Yüksel et al 2007,
Morris-Rosendahl et al 2010,
Dursun et al 2012,
Yildirim et al 2012,
Handley et al 2013,
Gillespie et al 2014,
Picker-Minh et al 2014,
Sawyer et al 2014,
Imagawa et al 2015,
Tasdemir et al 2015,
Gupta et al 2016,
Kabzińska et al 2016,
Rump et al 2016,
Srivastava et al 2016,
Patel et al 2017].
Pathogenic variants identified in RAB3GAP1 in more than one family include:
Recurrent pathogenic variants identified in individuals with different ethnic backgrounds include c.899+1G>A, c.1039C>T, and c.2801delC.
The apparent frameshift variant c.9delC was identified in sibs with Martsolf syndrome [Handley et al 2013] (see Genotype-Phenotype Correlations). Analysis of lymphoblast RNA from an affected child detected expression of an alternate RAB3GAP1 transcript, which may be sufficient to explain the milder Martsolf syndrome phenotype in this family.
Table 5.
RAB3GAP1 Pathogenic Variants Discussed in This GeneReview
View in own window
DNA Nucleotide Change | Predicted Protein Change (Alias 1) | Reference Sequences |
---|
c.9delC 2 | p.Asp4ThrTer31 (p.Asp4Thrfs*51) |
NM_012233.2
NP_036365.1
|
c.52A>C | p.Thr18Pro |
c.71A>T | p.Glu24Val |
c.560G>C | p.Arg187Pro |
c.649-2A>G | NA |
c.748+1G>A 3 | NA |
c.899+1G>A | NA |
c.1039C>T | p.Arg347Ter |
c.2801delC | p.Pro934LeufsTer87 |
c.2865_2866insTTCT | p.Pro956PheTer15 |
Variants listed in the table have been provided by the authors. GeneReviews staff have not independently verified the classification of variants.
GeneReviews follows the standard naming conventions of the Human Genome Variation Society (varnomen.hgvs.org). See Quick Reference for an explanation of nomenclature.
- 1.
Variant designation that does not conform to current naming conventions
- 2.
- 3.
Normal gene product. Functional characterization of RAB3GAP1 protein domains is limited. Biochemical evidence suggests that GTPase-activating protein ("GAP") activity specific for RAB3 isoforms resides in the C-terminal portion of the protein between amino acid residues 600 and 981 and identifies Arg728 as a critical residue in this activity [Clabecq et al 2000]. No evidence to date has definitively implicated loss of RAB3-GAP activity in, or excluded it from, a role in disease pathogenesis.
Abnormal gene product. Biochemical characterization of several of the disease-associated variants in RAB3GAP1 has been carried out [Gerondopoulos et al 2014].
Two of three pathogenic missense variants in RAB3GAP1, resulting in p.Thr18Pro and p.Glu24Val substitutions, disrupt the in vitro RAB18-GEF activity of the RAB3GAP1-RAB3GAP2 complex but do not affect the in vitro RAB3-GAP activity of RAB3GAP1. These data suggest that loss of RAB18-GEF activity is responsible for disease pathogenesis.
A third pathogenic missense variant, c.560G>C, p.Arg187Pro, has not been characterized at a molecular level [Asahina et al 2016].
The location of the loss-of-function missense variants in RAB3GAP1 may indicate that the N-terminal region of RAB3GAP1 is critical for its RAB18-GEF activity. However, the association of a c.9delC variant with Martsolf syndrome rather than Warburg micro syndrome [Handley et al 2013] suggests that the extreme N-terminus may be dispensable for the protein to retain some functional activity.
Two of the pathogenic variants in RAB3GAP1, c.2801delC and c.2865_2866insTTCT, affect the last exon of the gene and are therefore unlikely to reduce protein expression as a result of nonsense-mediated decay of the transcript [Aligianis et al 2005, Handley et al 2013]. This suggests that residues at the C-terminus of the protein, amino acids 934-981, are functionally important.
RAB3GAP2
Gene structure. The canonic RAB3GAP2 transcript, NM_012414, comprises 35 coding exons and encodes a 1,393-amino acid protein. For a detailed summary of gene and protein information, see Table A, Gene.
Pathogenic variants. In all affected individuals in the 11 families reported to date with RAB3GAP2 pathogenic variants, the variants have been homozygous [Aligianis et al 2006, Borck et al 2011, Handley et al 2013].
Nonsense variants were identified in five families, frameshift variants in two families, and missense variants in two families. An in-frame deletion and a variant affecting splicing were each identified in single families. One pathogenic missense RAB3GAP2 variant, c.1276C>T, p.Arg426Cys, was associated with Martsolf syndrome in two families of different ethnic origins.
Table 6.
RAB3GAP2 Pathogenic Variants Discussed in This GeneReview
View in own window
DNA Nucleotide Change | Predicted Protein Change (Alias) 1 | Reference Sequences |
---|
c.499_507del | p.Phe167_Thr169del |
NM_021414.3
NP_036546.2
|
c.1276C>T | p.Arg426Cys |
c.3154G>T | p.Gly1052Cys (Gly1051Cys) |
Variants listed in the table have been provided by the authors. GeneReviews staff have not independently verified the classification of variants.
GeneReviews follows the standard naming conventions of the Human Genome Variation Society (varnomen.hgvs.org). See Quick Reference for an explanation of nomenclature.
- 1.
Variant designation that does not conform to current naming conventions
Normal gene product. Functional characterization of RAB3GAP2 protein domains is limited.
Abnormal gene product. Characterization of the pathogenic p.Arg426Cys variant in RAB3GAP2 shows that this substitution disrupts the in vitro RAB18-GEF activity of the RAB3GAP1-RAB3GAP2 complex [Gerondopoulos et al 2014].
An in-frame deletion associated with Warburg micro syndrome, c.499_507del, removes conserved residues Phe167, Tyr168, and Thr169 from the protein, suggesting that these residues are also functionally important [Borck et al 2011].
RAB18
Gene structure. The canonic RAB18 transcript, NM_021252.4, comprises seven coding exons and encodes a 206-amino acid protein. Multiple poorly characterized alternatively-spliced RAB18 transcripts have been identified. One such transcript, NM_001256410, incorporates an additional exon encoding 29 additional amino acids, but this transcript has not been associated with disease. For a detailed summary of gene and protein information, see Table A, Gene.
Pathogenic variants. In nine families in which pathogenic variants have been reported to date, the variants were homozygous in eight and compound heterozygous in one [Bem et al 2011, Handley et al 2013, Gillespie et al 2014, Mandarano et al 2017].
A pathogenic founder variant, c.71T>A, is responsible for RAB18 deficiency in five families of ethnic Pakistani origin [Bem et al 2011, Gillespie et al 2014]. Other identified pathogenic variants are in Table 7.
Table 7.
RAB18 Pathogenic Variants Discussed in This GeneReview
View in own window
DNA Nucleotide Change | Predicted Protein Change | Reference Sequences |
---|
c.71T>A | p.Leu24Gln |
NM_021252.4
NP_067075.1
|
c.277_279del | p.Arg93del |
c.284C>G | p.Thr95Arg |
c.619T>C | p.Ter207GlnextTer20 1 |
Variants listed in the table have been provided by the authors. GeneReviews staff have not independently verified the classification of variants.
GeneReviews follows the standard naming conventions of the Human Genome Variation Society (varnomen.hgvs.org). See Quick Reference for an explanation of nomenclature.
- 1.
An extension variant with a sequence change in the translation termination (stop or Ter) codon 207 that extends the normal translational reading frame adding new amino acids and ending at new stop codon at position 20.
Normal gene product. A crystal structure of RAB18 has been generated (Protein Data Bank reference: 1X3S). In this structure, residues Gly15-Ser23, Phe33-Thr40, Asp63-Gln67, Asn122-Lys126, and Ala150-Lys153 are each in close proximity to bound nucleotide. Residues Lys21-Ser22, Ala38-Thr40, and Asp63-Thr64 are each in close proximity to bound magnesium. RAB18 has a C-terminal Cys-Ser-Val-Leu motif (amino acids 203-206) that is subject to post-translational modification. The Cys residue is geranylgeranylated, the terminal Ser-Val-Leu is then cleaved and the Cys residue is methylated [Leung et al 2007]. The geranylgeranyl-modification is important for the interactions of RAB18 with regulatory molecules and with membranes.
Abnormal gene product. A comparable clinical picture in individuals with a nonsense variant, a deletion of exon 2, and other pathogenic variants in this gene suggests that each of these variants completely abrogates protein function [Bem et al 2011, Mandarano et al 2017].
In vitro analyses of recombinant RAB18 p.Leu24Gln and p.Arg93del proteins shows that these variants completely abolish nucleotide binding [Bem et al 2011].
A c.284C>G, p.Thr95Arg variant has not been functionally characterized, but the proximity of Thr95 to Arg93 suggests that this substitution has a similar effect [Handley et al 2013].
A disease-associated extension variant, c.619T>C, is unlikely to impair nucleotide binding but is likely to compromise the post-translational modification of RAB18 and its association with membranes [Bem et al 2011].
Together, these data suggest that both nucleotide binding and post-translational modification are essential for RAB18 to function.
TBC1D20
Gene structure. The canonic TBC1D20 transcript, NM_144628.3, comprises eight coding exons and encodes a 403-amino acid protein (NP_653229.1).
Pathogenic variants. Pathogenic TBC1D20 variants have been homozygous in the affected children in all five families reported to date [Liegel et al 2013]. Nonsense variants were identified in three families; a frameshift variant and a deletion encompassing exons 2-8 were each identified in single families.
Normal gene product. TBC1D20 is a member of a family of homologous proteins, each containing a Tre2-Bub2-Cdc16 (TBC) domain. TBC domains have been found to confer RAB-GAP activity on these proteins, and each usually has a differing specificity for different RAB protein isoforms [Frasa et al 2012]. The TBC domain of TBC1D20 is located between amino acids 60 and 246. A crystal structure of TBC1D20 in a complex with RAB1B (Protein Data Bank reference: 4HLQ) has been described, and amino acid residues Arg105 and Gln144 shown to be important for catalytic activity [Gavriljuk et al 2012]. TBC1D20 contains a C-terminal transmembrane domain between amino acids 367 and 387 through which it associates with the membrane of the endoplasmic reticulum; this domain is likely to be essential for normal protein function.
Abnormal gene product. Each of the identified human pathogenic variants in TBC1D20 is likely to disrupt protein expression. A comparable clinical picture between an individual with a deletion encompassing exons 2-8 and the other affected individuals suggests that loss of protein expression is complete in each instance [Liegel et al 2013].
A pathogenic variant identified in the mutated mouse model, blind-sterile, is an in-frame deletion affecting five amino acids corresponding to Phe232-Val236 in the TBC domain of the human protein. The mutant protein of blind-sterile shows reduced stability and dramatically reduced catalytic activity as compared to its wild type counterpart suggesting that these residues are functionally important [Liegel et al 2013].