Clinical Description
Type II collagen is an essential component of the cartilage extracellular matrix, and of major importance in endochondral bone formation, growth, and normal joint function. It is also necessary for normal development and function of the eye and the inner ear. Type II collagen disorders encompass a diverse group of clinical phenotypes characterized by skeletal dysplasia, ocular manifestations (e.g., cataract, myopia, subluxation of the lens, vitreous abnormalities, retinal detachment), hearing impairment, and orofacial features [Nishimura et al 2005, Kannu et al 2012, Spranger et al 2012a, Terhal et al 2015, Savarirayan et al 2019].
The spectrum of severity ranges from severe perinatal-lethal disorders to milder conditions presenting in adulthood with premature arthrosis as the primary feature. Considerable phenotypic overlap notwithstanding, discriminating features can aid in the specific diagnosis (see Table 1). The following individual phenotypes are recognized in the 2023 revision of the Nosology of Genetic Skeletal Disorders [Unger et al 2023], and can be grouped according to severity.
Most severe (often lethal perinatally)
Achondrogenesis, COL2A1-related (formerly type II, type Langer-Saldino)
Hypochondrogenesis, COL2A1-related
Platyspondylic dysplasia, type Torrance, COL2A1-related
Severe / moderately severe (neonatal presentation)
Kniest dysplasia, COL2A1-related
Spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia congenita (SEDC), COL2A1-related
Spondyloepimetaphyseal dysplasia (SEMD), COL2A1-related
Intermediate (neonatal/childhood/adolescent presentation)
Spondyloperipheral dysplasia, COL2A1-related
Spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia (SED) with metatarsal shortening, COL2A1-related
Stickler syndrome, COL2A1-related
Mild (adolescent/adult presentation)
Most Severe (often lethal perinatally)
Achondrogenesis, COL2A1-related, is the most severe type II collagen disorder. Achondrogenesis, COL2A1-related, usually presents in the prenatal setting with short stature, extremely short limbs (micromelia), narrow chest with pulmonary hypoplasia, extraskeletal features (e.g., flat midface, Pierre Robin sequence [PRS]), and edema/hydropic appearance. Radiographic findings include poor ossification of the axial skeleton, absent or delayed ossification of the vertebral bodies, absent ossification of the sacrum, and absent or severely delayed ossification of pubic and ischial bones. Iliac bones are small with crescent-shaped inner and inferior margins. The distal femora and proximal tibiae show delayed ossification, and the ribs and tubular bones are short. The majority of these infants do not survive to term, and are often delivered prematurely, are stillborn, or die shortly after birth as a result of cardiorespiratory failure [Spranger et al 2012b].
Hypochondrogenesis, COL2A1-related, is characterized by short limbs, small thorax, flat facial profile, PRS, and delayed skeletal ossification, but with less severe clinical course and skeletal involvement than achondrogenesis, COL2A1-related. Vertebral bodies are small and ovoid, and unossified in the cervical region. The pubic bones are unossified and the ilia are hypoplastic. There is shortening of the long bones and delayed ossification in distal femoral and proximal tibial epiphyseal ossification centers. Infants with hypochondrogenesis have a short survival span ranging from days to months [Castori et al 2006].
Note: Achondrogenesis, COL2A1-related, and hypochondrogenesis, COL2A1-related, form one phenotypic continuum.
Platyspondylic dysplasia, type Torrance, COL2A1-related, is characterized by disproportionate short stature, short limbs, and coarse facial features. Skeletal findings consist of very thin vertebral bodies (severe platyspondyly), incomplete vertebral ossification, short ribs and narrow chest, short long bones with delayed/poor ossification, and splayed metaphyses of ribs and long bones. The majority of infants die at or shortly after birth; however, individuals with long-term survival have been reported [Nishimura et al 2004, Spranger et al 2012e, Handa et al 2021].
Severe / Moderately Severe (neonatal presentation)
Kniest dysplasia, COL2A1-related, is a very severe type II collagen disorder, but results in live birth and longer survival. The clinical presentation is characterized by severe disproportionate short stature, short neck, short thorax, short extremities, and distinct ocular findings: myopia, vitreal abnormalities, and retinal detachment. Radiographically, Kniest dysplasia, COL2A1-related, presents with pronounced abnormalities of bone modeling including platyspondyly with anterior wedging and coronal clefting of the lumbar vertebral bodies, delayed ossification in distal femoral and proximal tibial epiphyseal ossification centers, and short long bones with large metaphyses and epiphyses (dumbbell-type deformity of the long bones). Significant medical complications can occur mainly as a result of hypoplasia of the dens leading to cervical instability and spinal cord compression, tracheolaryngomalacia and related respiratory complications, and early-onset arthrosis [Yazici et al 2010, Spranger et al 2012c, Sergouniotis et al 2015, Handa et al 2021].
Spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia congenita (SEDC), COL2A1-related. Individuals with SEDC, COL2A1-related, present neonatally with severe disproportionate short stature, short extremities (<5th centile), characteristic facial features (hypertelorism, flat profile, PRS), myopia, and hearing loss. Radiographs display delayed/poor ossification of the vertebrae and the pubic bones, and the long bones are short with hypoplastic epiphyses. There is an increased risk for cervical instability and spinal cord compression (as seen in Kniest dysplasia, COL2A1-related), and individuals with SEDC, COL2A1-related, are also at greater risk for tracheolaryngomalacia and related respiratory complications.
SEDC, COL2A1-related, cannot be distinguished from spondyloepimetaphyseal dysplasia, COL2A1-related, until later in the first year of life, since metaphyseal dysplasia in the latter is not present at birth [Spranger et al 2012d, Terhal et al 2015].
Spondyloepimetaphyseal dysplasia (SEMD), COL2A1-related. Infants with SEMD, COL2A1-related, initially present with the same clinical and radiographic findings as those with SEDC, COL2A1-related. However, within the first year of life, metaphyseal flaring becomes evident, suggesting the diagnosis of SEMD, COL2A1-related. The clinical course is similar to that of SEDC, COL2A1-related, with increased risk for cervical instability and spinal cord compression posing the greatest risk for these individuals [Walter et al 2007, Terhal et al 2015, Handa et al 2021].
Intermediate (neonatal/childhood/adolescent presentation)
Spondyloperipheral dysplasia, COL2A1-related, is characterized by mild-to-moderate disproportionate short stature and short extremities, brachydactyly type E, short ulnae, variable clubfeet, cleft palate, myopia, and hearing loss. Radiographs show ovoid vertebra, delayed ossification of pubic bones, and flattened and irregular epiphyses in the long bones in addition to the brachydactyly and short ulnae. Premature hip arthrosis causes joint pain [Zankl et al 2004, Handa et al 2021].
Spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia (SED) with metatarsal shortening, COL2A1-related, is characterized by severe joint pain in the lower limbs before adolescence and shortening of the postaxial toes (usually the 3rd and/or 4th toes). Height is average, and ocular and orofacial abnormalities are absent. Radiographs are characterized by mild platyspondyly with irregular end plates, narrowed intervertebral spaces, signs of osteoarthrosis including deformed femoral heads and dysplastic pelvis with irregular acetabulae, and shortening of the metatarsal and metacarpal bones [Kozlowski et al 2004, Marik et al 2004, Hoornaert et al 2007, Handa et al 2021].
Stickler syndrome, COL2A1-related, is one of the milder and more frequent type II collagen disorders [Barat-Houari et al 2016b, Barat-Houari et al 2016c], and the most common type of Stickler syndrome. It shows remarkable inter- and intrafamilial phenotypic variation, with severity ranging from involvement of many organs to milder phenotypes with only ocular manifestations and clinical and radiographic findings of early-onset osteoarthrosis. The ocular manifestations include high myopia, congenital membranous vitreous abnormalities (most often type 1 congenital vitreous anomaly or "membranous" vitreous phenotype), retinal detachment, and early-onset cataract. The orofacial abnormalities include flat facial profile (underdevelopment of the maxilla and nasal bridge), isolated small jaw, isolated cleft palate, or a combination (PRS), and hearing loss that can be conductive and/or sensorineural. The musculoskeletal manifestations include mild short stature or average stature, joint hypermobility, and skeletal dysplasia. Radiographic features include mild-to-moderate flattening of the vertebra with or without end plate irregularities, and irregular epiphyses of the long bones [Szymko-Bennett et al 2001, Liberfarb et al 2003, Rose et al 2005, Snead et al 2011, Acke et al 2012]. Typically, phenotypic findings present in childhood or later, although micrognathia, cleft palate, and polyhydramnios have been detected on prenatal ultrasound [Soulier et al 2002, Pacella et al 2010, Handa et al 2021].
Mild (adolescent/adult presentation)
Mild spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia (SED) with premature-onset arthrosis is the mildest form of type II collagen disorder. It is characterized clinically by progressive joint pain and limitation of motion of the hip and knee joints, and radiographically by epiphyseal dysplasia and early-onset osteoarthrosis. The manifestations are age dependent, and height, vision, hearing, and orofacial structures are usually normal [Su et al 2008, Kannu et al 2010, Kannu et al 2011, Handa et al 2021]. In the 2023 revision of the Nosology of Genetic Skeletal Disorders [Unger et al 2023], mild SED with premature-onset arthrosis is included under SEDC, COL2A1-related.
Table 1.
Clinical and Radiographic Features of Type II Collagen Disorders from Most to Least Severe
View in own window
COL2A1-Related Disorder | Age of Diagnosis | Poor/ Delayed Ossification | Stature | Extraskeletal Abnormalities | Distinguishing Feature(s) 1 |
---|
Clinical | Radiographic |
---|
Most severe (often lethal perinatally) 2
|
Achondrogenesis | Prenatal | ++++++ | Extremely short | Flat midface; PRS; hydropic appearance | Often delivered prematurely, stillborn, or die shortly after birth (hrs) | Absent or severely delayed ossification of vertebral bodies; short ribs; absent ossification of pubic bones, sacrum, & ischial & iliac bones (small w/crescent-shaped inner & inferior margins); very short tubular bones w/delayed ossification in distal femoral & proximal tibial epiphyseal ossification centers |
Hypochondrogenesis | Prenatal | +++++ | Extremely short | Flat midface; PRS | Majority alive at birth, short survival (days to mos) | Poor/delayed ossification of axial skeleton; very short tubular bones in prenatal period; short ribs; vertebral bodies are small & ovoid, & unossified in cervical region; unossified pubic bones; hypoplastic ilia; short & relatively broad long bones w/delayed ossification in distal femoral & proximal tibial epiphysis |
Platyspondylic dysplasia, type Torrance | Prenatal | +++++ | Extremely short | Coarse facial features | Majority alive at birth, short survival (days to mos) | Platyspondyly; incomplete vertebral ossification; short ribs & narrow chest; splayed metaphyses of ribs & long bones |
Severe to moderately severe (neonatal presentation)
|
Kniest dysplasia | Perinatal | ++++ | Short | PRS; high prevalence of myopia, lens subluxation, retinal detachment, & other vitreal abnormalities; ↑ risk of tracheolaryngomalacia | Most severe type II collagen disorder resulting in live birth; long-term joint problems; risk of cervical instability & myelopathy | Platyspondyly w/anterior wedging in low thoracic & lumbar region; coronal cleft vertebral bodies; delayed ossification in distal femoral & proximal tibial epiphyseal ossification centers; dumbbell-type deformity of long bones (large metaphyses & epiphyses) |
SEDC | Perinatal | +++ | Short | Flat facial profile, hypertelorism, PRS; ocular abnormalities; ↑ risk of tracheolaryngomalacia | Severe disproportionate short stature/extremities (˂5th %ile); ↑ risk of cervical instability & spinal cord compression | Delayed/absent ossification of pubic bones, spine, & distal femoral & proximal tibial epiphyseal ossification centers; delayed carpal & tarsal ossification |
SEMD | Perinatal | +++ | Short | Delayed ossification of pubic bones, spine, & distal femoral & proximal tibial epiphyseal ossification centers; metaphyseal dysplasia in 1st year of life (distinguishing SEMD, Strudwick type, from SEDC) |
Intermediate (neonatal/childhood/adolescent presentation)
|
Spondyloperipheral dysplasia | Perinatal/infancy | ++ | Short | Myopia; hearing loss | Moderate-to-mild disproportionate short stature; short extremities; brachydactyly; occasionally clubfeet | Ovoid vertebra & irregular epiphyses in long bones; brachydactyly type E; short ulnae |
SED w/metatarsal shortening | Before adolescence | Normal | Average | Usually no extraskeletal abnormalities | Typical phenotypic hallmark: shortening of 3rd & 4th toes; severe joint pain | Platyspondyly w/irregular end plates; narrowed intervertebral spaces; early osteoarthrosis in spine & lower limb joints (deformed femoral heads & dysplastic pelvis); metatarsal hypoplasia involving postaxial toes |
Stickler syndrome | Variable (typically perinatal if cleft palate) | Normal | Mild short to average | High risk of high myopia, congenital membranous vitreous abnormalities, retinal detachment, & cataract; U-shaped cleft palate; auditory manifestations | In case of PRS, diagnosis most often in infancy | Radiographic appearance of precocious or inflammatory arthritis (childhood) |
Mild (adolescent/adult presentation)
|
Mild SED w/premature-onset arthrosis | Adolescence/adulthood | Normal | Average | Vision, hearing, & orofacial structures are usually normal. | Progressive joint pain & limitation of motion of hip & knee joint | Epiphyseal dysplasia & early-onset osteoarthrosis |
PRS = Pierre Robin sequence; SED = spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia; SEDC = spondyloepiphyseal dysplasia congenita; SEMD = spondyloepimetaphyseal dysplasia
- 1.
Features distinguishing this disorder from other type II collagen disorders
- 2.
Can be very difficult to distinguish prenatally