Clinical Description
GNB5-related neurodevelopmental disorder (GNB5-NDD) is characterized by a spectrum of neurodevelopmental phenotypes that range from severe-to-profound intellectual disability (ID; 31/41 individuals, ~75%), to mild-to-moderate ID (5/41 individuals, ~12%), to normal intellect with severe language disorder (5/41 individuals, from one family, ~12%; see Neurodevelopmental Disorder, Impaired language development without ID). A unique and specific feature of GNB5-NDD – regardless of neurodevelopmental phenotype – is nearly universal bradycardia caused by sinoatrial node dysfunction (sick sinus syndrome). Most individuals with severe and profound ID have a developmental and epileptic encephalopathy with focal seizures or epileptic spasms, as well as visual impairment (central or retinal) with nystagmus, difficulty feeding, and gastroesophageal reflux disease. The risk of early mortality is increased.
To date, 41 individuals with biallelic GNB5 pathogenic variants have been identified [Lodder et al 2016, Shamseldin et al 2016, Turkdogan et al 2017, Malerba et al 2018, Vernon et al 2018, Poke et al 2019, Mai et al 2020, Tang et al 2020, Yazdani et al 2020, De Nittis et al 2021]. The following description of the phenotypic features associated with this condition is based on these reports (see Table 2).
Neurodevelopmental Disorder
Cognitive outcome is variable. Severe-to-profound ID is seen in ~75%, mild-to-moderate ID in ~12%, and normal intellect with a severe language disorder in ~12% (one family).
Severe-to-profound ID. Children who manifest developmental abnormalities in the first months of life eventually have severe or profound ID. They are often nonambulatory and nonverbal. Developmental regression is rare [Yazdani et al 2020]. Of the children who developed epilepsy, all were delayed before seizure onset. Two children required enteral tube feeding [Poke et al 2019, Yazdani et al 2020].
Mild-to-moderate ID. In the five children reported with mild-to-moderate ID, language development was more affected than motor skills.
Of the three individuals reported by Lodder et al [2016], two sibs (ages 8 and 13 years) were nonverbal, and the younger sib was noted to have impaired fine motor skills; the third individual (age 23 years) had mild ID with no information on verbal skills.
Malerba et al [2018] reported a girl age 2.5 years with a developmental quotient of 50-55; she used sign language and had 12 spoken words. She was reported to be social, curious, and interactive with a high activity level and short attention span.
De Nittis et al [2021] reported a girl age seven years who walked at 31 months and was nonverbal, but used sign language and was considered to have mild ID (a formal neuropsychological assessment was not performed). She was enrolled in a special education class.
Impaired language development without ID. One extended family is reported with five affected children (ages 3-10 years) from three sibships. Children were reported to have normal cognitive function despite severe receptive and expressive language abnormalities [Shamseldin et al 2016]. Two children (ages 5 and 10 years) had IQs of 80 and 110 (Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children). Two children (ages 3 and 9 years) did not have formal cognitive assessments but clinical assessment was consistent with normal intelligence. Data was lacking for the fifth child. Three of the children had fine motor delay that was less severe than their language problems.
Other Neurodevelopmental Features
Hypotonia and hyporeflexia are common initially and are near universal in children with severe or profound ID. Hypertonia, spasticity, and joint contractures develop in a minority. At least one individual required surgery for hamstring contractures [Author, personal observation].
Attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) was reported in 3/5 children with language delay but normal IQ; ADHD as assessed by DSM-IV criteria was either hyperactive or inattentive [Shamseldin et al 2016]. Autism or autistic traits were reported in 4/32 with severe-to-profound ID [Turkdogan et al 2017, De Nittis et al 2021].
Sinus Node Dysfunction
The presence or absence of cardiac involvement does not correlate with the level of developmental impairment.
Bradycardia due to sinus node dysfunction (sick sinus syndrome), the most common arrhythmia, may present with cyanosis or apnea, or be asymptomatic and incidentally picked up on EKG. Bradycardia may be identified prenatally [Malerba et al 2018]. In some instances bradycardia was more pronounced during sleep [Lodder et al 2016, Mai et al 2020]. The bradycardia can be extreme, with periods of asystole.
Animal models suggest that GNB5 is crucial for parasympathetic control of heart rate but not sympathetic control. Hence, heart rates at rest may be very slow (commonly <25 beats per minute), but with preserved positive chronotropic response at times of stress or excitement to rates greater than 150 beats per minute [Lodder et al 2016].
Other arrhythmias rarely reported [Lodder et al 2016, Tang et al 2020]:
AV block (2 individuals)
Atrial tachycardia (1 individual)
Atrial fibrillation (1 individual)
Sinus tachycardia (1 individual)
Six children had a pacemaker inserted; four had profound ID and two had mild-to-moderate ID [Lodder et al 2016, Malerba et al 2018, Vernon et al 2018, Yazdani et al 2020]. Only two had symptomatic bradycardia [Lodder et al 2016]; however, one child without definite cardiac symptoms was noted to have improved balance and fewer falls after pacemaker insertion [Malerba et al 2018]. The other four had pacemakers inserted due to the length and/or frequency of cardiac pauses on monitoring. When one child's depleted pacemaker battery was not replaced, no adverse cardiac events occurred in the ensuing five years [Yazdani et al 2020].
Epilepsy
Twenty-six individuals had a developmental and epileptic encephalopathy, presenting with developmental delay prior to seizure onset [Lodder et al 2016, Turkdogan et al 2017, Poke et al 2019, Mai et al 2020, Sciacca et al 2020, Tang et al 2020, Yazdani et al 2020, De Nittis et al 2021].
The median age at seizure onset was six months (range: 1 week to 3 years).
In the 16 individuals for whom detailed seizure semiology (i.e., seizure type) was provided, the first seizure type was epileptic spasms in seven, focal motor seizures in seven, and tonic-clonic seizures in two. The most common seizure type overall was epileptic spasms (onset age: 2 months to 3 years), which can occur either at seizure presentation or later.
While EEGs may be normal in the first weeks of life, by age three to six months there is burst suppression or hypsarrhythmia, and by age three years multifocal discharges with background slowing [Poke et al 2019].
Visual Impairment
Visual impairment is common in children with severe-to-profound ID; it has not been reported in children with mild ID.
Nystagmus affects nearly all children with severe-to-profound ID. Both upbeat nystagmus [Vernon et al 2018] and horizontal nystagmus [Mai et al 2020, De Nittis et al 2021] is described. While some children with nystagmus may have retinopathy or cortical visual impairment [Yazdani et al 2020], others have no retinal disease [De Nittis et al 2021] and normal visual evoked potentials [Mai et al 2020].
Retinopathy in GNB5-NDD is due to phototransduction recovery deficit in both rod and cone photoreceptors (bradyopsia) and rod ON-bipolar cell dysfunction [Shao et al 2020]. Abnormal findings on fundoscopy are infrequent. Three individuals were reported with optic atrophy or disc pallor [Poke et al 2019, Yazdani et al 2020, Shao et al 2020] and two sibs with reduced retinal pigmentation [De Nittis et al 2021]. The relative contribution of retinopathy and cortical dysfunction to visual impairment is unclear. Visual impairment may affect other aspects of development.
Strabismus is described in six individuals with severe-to-profound ID and one with moderate ID [Malerba et al 2018, Poke et al 2019, Yazdani et al 2020, De Nittis et al 2021].
Myopic refractive errors, described in two children ages two and three years with severe-to-profound ID, measured -1.5 diopters in the younger child [De Nittis et al 2021] and -2.0/-3.0 diopters in the older [Shao et al 2020].
Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease
Pathologic gastric reflux disease (common in children with severe-to-profound ID) may be severe, resulting in hospitalization and/or bleeding [Yazdani et al 2020]. Only two individuals have required long-term gastrostomy tube feeding: one in infancy for failure to thrive, and the other at age five years due to the increased risk of aspiration [Poke et al 2019, Yazdani et al 2020].
Other
Birth weight is usually normal. Postnatal microcephaly or macrocephaly are uncommon. Limited data on other postnatal growth parameters are available.
Brain imaging is usually normal. Occasionally nonspecific changes including prominent cerebrospinal fluid spaces, cerebral or cerebellar atrophy, and/or a thin corpus callosum are noted [Lodder et al 2016, Vernon et al 2018, Poke et al 2019, Tang et al 2020, De Nittis et al 2021].
Mortality
Three individuals with confirmed pathogenic variants in GNB5 died in childhood [Poke et al 2019, De Nittis et al 2021]. An additional five untested sibs with similar clinical findings also died in childhood [Turkdogan et al 2017, De Nittis et al 2021].
Age at death, reported in 7/8 individuals, ranged from five months to 13 years; all had severe or profound developmental impairment and epilepsy. Circumstances of death were reported in six of the eight:
A girl age five months died during severe acute gastroenteritis.
Her brother and sister died at seven and eight months, respectively, during sleep; death was attributed to sudden unexpected death in epilepsy (SUDEP).
Another brother presented to hospital with sinus bradycardia and died with multiorgan failure at age seven years.
A girl age 13 years died in her sleep, possibly from a cardiac arrhythmia or SUDEP [
Poke et al 2019].
No publications mentioned coroners' reports.