Tarsal tunnel syndrome secondary to accessory or variant muscles: a clinical and anatomical systematic review

Purpose: Many etiologies are known to lead to a tarsal tunnel syndrome (TTS). One rare cause is mass-occupying lesions, and particularly accessory or variant muscles (AVM). This study aimed to systematically collect published clinical cases of TTS caused by AVM.

Methods: An electronic literature search was conducted from inception to April 2021. The diagnosis of AVM should be reported in one of the following methods: ultrasonography, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), or per-operatively. Data extraction included types and prevalence of accessory muscles, clinical presentation and diagnosis, and treatment modalities. Twenty-five studies were identified with a total 39 patients (47 ankles).

Results: The prevalence of TTS was reported in only two studies (9%). Forty-nine AVM were identified with the accessory flexor digitorum longus being the most common (52%). The most common sign/symptoms were tenderness (78.7%), pain (82.9%), dysesthesia (57.4%), Tinel sign (44.6%), and a swelling (25.5%). Decompression and excision were the most commonly performed procedures. Four accessory/variant muscles in the ankle have the potential to induce a tarsal tunnel syndrome.

Conclusion: This review highlights the clinical and imagery specificities of TTS secondary to accessory or variant muscles. Mass-occupying etiology should be included in the list of differential diagnoses whenever a posterior tibial nerve compression is suspected.