Table 20Mean total costs and QALYs for all modelled comparators

Strategy (a)Mean Cost (£)95% CI (£)Mean Benefit (QALYs)95% CI (QALYs)Mean NMB @£20k
PS BD - Concurrent - Coal Tar BD226109to4040.84870.8022to0.887716748
Concurrent - PS BD - Coal tar BD236125to4070.84910.8024to0.888616747
PS BD - Concurrent - Vit D BD238117to4120.84860.8019to0.887516735
Concurrent - PS BD - Vit D BD247133to4150.84900.8022to0.888516734
PS BD - Vit D BD - Concurrent255137to4200.84830.8015to0.887416712
Concurrent - Vit D BD - PS BD272150to4350.84880.8021to0.888416705
PS BD - Concurrent - Dithranol OD267127to4660.84830.8016to0.887516699
Concurrent - PS BD - Dithranol OD276140to4670.84870.8021to0.888416698
PS BD - Vit D OD - Concurrent268139to4500.84790.8014to0.887116690
PS OD - PS BD - Coal Tar BD249110to4310.84660.8004to0.886116682
PS BD - Vit D BD - Coal Tar BD279147to4490.84780.8009to0.887116678
Vit D BD - PS BD - Concurrent276178to4220.84760.8008to0.887016676
Concurrent - Vit D BD - Coal Tar BD301158to4980.84850.8017to0.888116669
PS OD - Concurrent - Coal tar BD269115to4840.84680.8004to0.886216667
Vit D BD - Concurrent - PS BD289190to4360.84770.8010to0.887016665
PS OD - PS BD - Vit D BD264122to4410.84640.8002to0.885916665
PS BD - Vit D BD - TCF OD319172to5100.84870.8019to0.887716654
PS BD - Vit D OD - Coal Tar BD295151to4710.84740.8007to0.886516652
PS OD - Concurrent - Vit D BD284123to4930.84670.8002to0.886016650
Concurrent - Vit D BD - TCF OD339175to5610.84930.8028to0.888816646
Vit D OD - PS BD - Concurrent285173to4520.84650.8004to0.885916645
Vit D BD - PS BD - Coal Tar BD300187to4530.84710.8003to0.886216642
PS BD - Vit D OD - Vit D BD310165to4870.84720.8003to0.886516635
PS OD - PS BD - Vit D OD285117to4830.84600.7994to0.885616634
Vit D OD - Concurrent - PS BD299185to4640.84660.8004to0.885916633
Vit D BD - PS OD - PS BD302187to4540.84670.8000to0.886116631
PS OD - Vit D BD - PS BD294149to4610.84620.7998to0.885616630
PS BD - TCF OD - Coal Tar BD353197to5450.84920.8027to0.888116630
Vit D BD - Concurrent - Coal tar BD318199to4970.84740.8008to0.886616629
Vit D BD - PS OD - Concurrent311182to4910.84680.8000to0.886016625
PS OD - Vit D BD - Concurrent303145to4980.84640.7999to0.885616625
Concurrent - TCF OD - Coal tar BD371194to6010.84970.8032to0.889116624
PS BD - Vit D OD - TCF OD342175to5550.84820.8017to0.887316622
Vit D BD - PS BD - TCF OD339214to5130.84790.8014to0.887116620
PS BD - Vit D BD - Dithranol OD328172to5200.84730.8002to0.886916618
PS OD - PS BD - Dithranol OD302138to4980.84600.7994to0.885516618
PS BD - TCF OD - Vit D BD364204to5540.84910.8023to0.888016618
Concurrent - Vit D BD - Dithranol OD347175to5580.84800.8014to0.887716614
Concurrent - TCF OD - Vit D BD381197to6100.84970.8030to0.889216612
PS BD - Concurrent - Referral335161to5480.84720.8004to0.886416609
Concurrent - PS BD - Referral344176to5510.84760.8006to0.887416608
Vit D OD - PS BD - Coal tar OD311184to4740.84600.7999to0.885416608
Vit D BD - Concurrent - TCF OD356216to5600.84810.8014to0.887416606
PS OD - Concurrent - Dithranol OD320134to5560.84630.7996to0.885616606
PS OD - Vit D OD - PS BD311139to5000.84560.7992to0.885416602
PS OD - Vit D OD - Concurrent323134to5570.84580.7992to0.885116593
Vit D OD - Concurrent - Coal tar BD332193to5370.84620.8000to0.885716592
Vit D OD - PS BD - Vit D BD327202to4870.84580.7995to0.885416589
Vit D OD - PS OD - PS BD318177to4930.84540.7991to0.884916589
PS BD - TCF OD - Dithranol OD389214to5990.84880.8019to0.888016587
PS BD - Vit D OD - Dithranol OD350181to5450.84680.7998to0.886316586
Vit D BD - PS OD - Coal Tar BD340198to5250.84620.7999to0.885616584
Vit D BD - PS BD - Dithranol OD348217to5210.84660.7996to0.886116584
PS OD - Vit D BD - Coal Tar BD332156to5310.84580.7993to0.885316584
Concurrent - TCF OD - Dithranol OD405205to6580.84940.8028to0.889016582
Vit D OD - PS OD - Concurrent330172to5490.84550.7991to0.884916581
Vit D OD - PS BD - TCF OD359209to5560.84680.8005to0.886316577
TCF OD - PS BD - Coal Tar BD428290to5750.85020.8041to0.889416576
Vit D OD - Concurrent - Vit D BD347201to5400.84610.7996to0.885516575
Vit D BD - Concurrent - Dithranol OD364217to5570.84690.8004to0.886416574
TCF OD - PS BD - Vit D BD438300to5810.85010.8038to0.889216564
Vit D OD - Concurrent - TCF OD379207to6250.84700.8009to0.886316561
Vit D OD - Vit D BD - PS BD357236to5050.84560.7994to0.885216555
Vit D BD - PS OD - TCF OD391217to6110.84710.8006to0.886316552
PS OD - Vit D BD - TCF OD383177to6200.84670.8000to0.885916551
Vit D OD - Vit D BD - Concurrent367230to5450.84580.7993to0.885316548
PS OD - Vit D OD - Coal tar BD355148to5820.84510.7989to0.884916548
Vit D OD - PS BD - Dithranol OD366217to5470.84540.7989to0.885116541
TCF OD - Vit D BD - PS BD461322to6020.84990.8035to0.889216538
Vit D OD - PS OD - Coal tar BD362185to5750.84490.7987to0.884516535
TCF OD - PS BD - Dithranol OD463310to6240.84980.8034to0.888916533
Vit D BD - TCF OD - PS BD432296to5900.84820.8016to0.887216531
Vit D OD - Concurrent - Dithranol OD385213to6040.84570.7991to0.885216528
PS OD - Vit D OD - Vit D BD375162to5880.84500.7984to0.884716525
PS OD - TCF OD - Coal Tar BD421200to6600.84730.8007to0.886816524
Concurrent - Vit D BD - Referral421218to6430.84680.7998to0.886616515
PS BD - Vit D BD - referral407233to5920.84600.7989to0.885516513
Vit D OD - PS OD - Vit D BD381200to5800.84470.7985to0.884216513
Vit D BD - PS OD - Dithranol OD400233to5900.84560.7989to0.885216512
PS OD - Vit D BD - Dithranol OD392191to5980.84520.7983to0.884716511
PS OD - TCF OD - Vit D BD434207to6700.84720.8004to0.886416509
TCF OD - Vit D BD - Coal Tar BD486331to6500.84960.8035to0.888816507
PS BD - TCF OD - Referral450254to6720.84780.8012to0.887016507
Concurrent - TCF OD - Referral463232to7430.84850.8013to0.888016506
Vit D OD - Vit D BD - Coal Tar BD397248to5740.84510.7990to0.884616506
PS OD - Vit D OD - TCF OD417161to7190.84610.7994to0.885716505
PS OD - PS BD - Referral387190to5830.84460.7979to0.884416505
PS OD - Concurrent - Referral399169to6490.84500.7980to0.884516500
Vit D BD - TCF OD - Coal Tar BD458307to6410.84790.8013to0.886916499
Vit D OD - Vit D BD - PS OD401235to5890.84470.7983to0.884216494
Vit D OD - PS OD - TCF OD424201to7110.84590.7996to0.885116493
Vit D OD - TCF OD - PS BD458291to6380.84700.8009to0.886516483
Vit D BD - PS BD - Referral428279to5920.84530.7983to0.884716478
Vit D BD - Concurrent - Referral438262to6430.84570.7989to0.885416476
Vit D OD - Vit D BD - TCF OD450273to6600.84610.7999to0.885516472
PS OD - TCF OD - Dithranol OD466214to7300.84680.7999to0.886016470
PS BD - Vit D OD - Referral437248to6280.84530.7986to0.885016469
PS OD - Vit D OD - Dithranol OD424175to6720.84440.7979to0.884216464
TCF OD - Vit D BD - Dithranol OD526354to7010.84920.8026to0.888416458
TCF OD - PS BD - Referral525352to6980.84890.8024to0.888216452
Vit D OD - PS OD - Dithranol OD431217to6640.84410.7976to0.883816452
Vit D BD - TCF OD - Dithranol OD498330to6940.84740.8008to0.886916451
Vit D OD - TCF OD - Coal Tar BD488300to7040.84670.8008to0.886216446
Vit D OD - Vit D BD - Dithranol OD459288to6440.84450.7981to0.884216431
Vit D OD - TCF OD - Vit D BD502308to7090.84660.8004to0.885916430
Vit D OD - PS BD - Referral454283to6290.84390.7975to0.883916424
Vit D OD - Concurrent - Referral467253to6970.84430.7975to0.883916418
Vit D OD - TCF OD - Dithranol OD535317to7710.84620.7997to0.885516389
Vit D BD - PS OD - Referral492293to6720.84400.7974to0.883716388
PS OD - Vit D BD - Referral484251to6800.84360.7968to0.883416387
PS OD - TCF OD - Referral540244to8310.84560.7988to0.885316371
TCF OD - Vit D BD - Referral594399to7770.84810.8015to0.887516369
Vit D BD - TCF OD - Referral565375to7730.84640.7999to0.885916362
PS OD - Vit D OD - Referral526228to7640.84260.7956to0.882716325
Vit D OD - PS OD - Referral533270to7570.84230.7954to0.882316313
Vit D OD - Vit D BD - Referral554366to7210.84280.7963to0.882916303
Vit D OD - TCF OD - Referral611352to8670.84490.7986to0.884416288
Vehicle only664605to7270.83580.7887to0.875816052
a

Ranked in order of total net monetary benefit at a threshold willingness to pay of £20,000 per QALY gained

From: Appendix M, Cost-effectiveness analysis trunk and limbs

Cover of Psoriasis
Psoriasis: Assessment and Management of Psoriasis.
NICE Clinical Guidelines, No. 153.
National Clinical Guideline Centre (UK).
Copyright © National Clinical Guideline Centre - October 2012.

Apart from any fair dealing for the purposes of research or private study, criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored or transmitted in any form or by any means, without the prior written permission of the publisher or, in the case of reprographic reproduction, in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency in the UK. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the terms stated here should be sent to the publisher at the UK address printed on this page.

The use of registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant laws and regulations and therefore for general use.

The rights of National Clinical Guideline Centre to be identified as Author of this work have been asserted by them in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988.

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.