Summary Table 38. General category

Author, year, LocationSample descriptionNo. EligibleMeasurement PeriodRate (%)/ Key Differences
Appropriate use of definitive locoregional therapy (total mastectomy + axillary lymph node dissection, or, breast-conserving surgery + axillary lymph node dissection + radiotherapy) IV
Nattinger, 2000, USNational population-based sample women ≥30 y at the time of first diagnosis of invasive local or regional unilateral BC144,759199578%/NA
Hebert-Croteau, 1999, CanadaRandom sample newly diagnosed stage I–II BC women ≥50 y treated in Quebec1,1741993-1994NR/Age: 50–69 y: 83.5%; ≥70 y: 48.7%
Silliman, 1999, USConvenience sample women ≥55 y newly diagnosed stage I or II BC treated 1 center in Boston303NR77.2% (Surgery type: BCS + RT: 56%; Mastectomy: 22%)/ Income: ≤U$14,999: 55%; 15,000–29, 999: 85%; 30,000–49,999: 91%; ≥50,000: 87%/Education: < high school: 55%; high school: 75%; some college: 83%; college: 82%
Appropriate use of alternative definitive therapy (radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery + axillary lymph node dissection or adjuvant treatment) IV
Hebert-Croteau, 1999, CanadaRandom sample newly diagnosed stage I–II BC women ≥50 y treated in Quebec1,1741993-1994NR/Age: 50–69 y: 90.9%; ≥70 y: 60.9%
Silliman, 1999, USConvenience sample women ≥55 y newly diagnosed stage I or II BC treated 1 center in Boston303NR51.8%/Age: 55–64 y: 50%; 65–74 y: 41%; 75–84 y: 9%
Cases not receiving recommended treatment (radiotherapy after breast-conserving surgery or systemic therapy) due to system failure IV
Bickell, 2003, USConvenience sample women ESBC who had treatment underuse; not RT or adjuvant therapy recommended when indicated441998-199932%/NA
Appropriate use: Women with metastatic cancer should be offered hormonal therapy, chemotherapy, and/or enrollment in a clinical trial with documentation of informed consent, within 6 weeks of the identification of metastases IV
McGlynn, 2003, USRandom sample of women living in 12 US metropolitan areas41998-200082.6%/NA

From: Summary Tables

Cover of Measuring the Quality of Breast Cancer Care in Women
Measuring the Quality of Breast Cancer Care in Women.
Evidence Reports/Technology Assessments, No. 105.
Schachter HM, Mamaladze V, Lewin G, et al.

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.