Table 13Summary GRADE table (ESTEP tutoring programme vs No ESTEP tutoring)

OutcomeSample sizeEffect size (95% CI)QualityInterpretation of effecta
Mean letter-word identification score at approximately 26 months follow up: assessed by Woodcock–Johnson Tests of Achievement III.529MD 2.10 (−2.25 to 6.45)Very lowNo meaningful effect
Mean calculation score at approximately 26 months follow up: assessed by Woodcock–Johnson Tests of Achievement III529MD −0.30 (−4.22 to 3.62)Very lowNo meaningful effect
Mean passage comprehension score at approximately 26 months follow up: assessed by Woodcock–Johnson Tests of Achievement III529MD −0.20 (−4.33 to 3.93)Very lowNo meaningful effect
Mean highest grade level completion at approximately 26 months follow up: self-report529MD 0.00 (−0.19 to 0.19)Very lowNo meaningful effect
Mean grade point average at follow up at approximately 26 months follow up: Participants reported their school grades they had received across four core subjects during their previous full semester of school. Responses were scored based on a standard 4-point scale, and an overall GPA was computed by taking the average of these.529MD 0.00 (−0.18 to 0.18)Very lowNo meaningful effect
School behaviour score: youths were asked to indicate how often they had had “trouble” completing five tasks during their last full semester of school attendance. School behaviour was then operationalised or defined as the mean of these five items.529MD −0.02 (−0.25 to 0.21)Very lowNo meaningful effect
Achieving high school diploma or general equivalency diploma at approximately 26 months follow up: self-report529OR 0.79 (0.41 to 1.52)Very lowCould not differentiate
(a)

No meaningful difference: crosses line of no effect but not line of MID; Could not differentiate: crosses line of no effect and line of MID; May favour: confidence intervals do not cross line of no effect but cross MID; Favours: confidence intervals do not cross line of no effect or MID

From: Interventions to support learning needs for school-aged looked-after children and young people

Cover of Interventions to support learning needs for school-aged looked-after children and young people
Interventions to support learning needs for school-aged looked-after children and young people: Looked-After Children and Young People: Evidence review I.
NICE Guideline, No. 205.
Copyright © NICE 2021.

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.