Table 1. Comparison of Diagnostic Criteria for Basal Cell Nevus Syndrome (BCNS)

Evans et al. 1993 [49]Kimonis et al. 1997 [50]Veenstra-Knol et al. 2005 [51]BCNS Colloquium Group 2011b [52]
Major Criteriaa
>2 BCCs or 1 BCC diagnosed before age 30 y or >10 basal cell nevi>2 BCCs or 1 BCC diagnosed before age 20 y>2 BCCs or 1 BCC diagnosed before age 20 yBCC before age 20 y or excessive number of BCCs out of proportion with previous skin exposure and skin type
Histologically proven odontogenic keratocyst or polyostotic bone cystHistologically proven odontogenic keratocystHistologically proven odontogenic keratocystOdontogenic keratocyst of jaw before age 20 y
≥3 palmar or plantar pits≥3 palmar or plantar pits≥3 palmar or plantar pitsPalmar or plantar pitting
Ectopic calcifications, lamellar or early (diagnosed before age 20 y) faux calcificationsBilamellar calcification of faux cerebriEctopic calcification (lamellar or early faux cerebri)Lamellar calcification of falx cerebri
Family history of BCNSFirst-degree relative with BCNSFamily history of BCNSFirst-degree relative with BCNS
(Rib abnormalities listed as minor criterion; see below.)Bifid, fused, or splayed ribsBifid, fused, or splayed ribs(Rib abnormalities listed as minor criterion; see below.)
(Medulloblastoma listed as minor criterion; see below.)(Medulloblastoma listed as minor criterion; see below.)(Medulloblastoma listed as minor criterion; see below.)Medulloblastoma (usually desmoplastic)
Minor Criteria
Occipital-frontal circumference >97th percentile and frontal bossingMacrocephaly (adjusted for height)Macrocephaly (>97th percentile)Macrocephaly
Congenital skeletal abnormalities: bifid, fused, splayed, or missing rib or bifid, wedged, or fused vertebraeBridging of sella turcica, vertebral abnormalities (hemivertebrae, fusion or elongation of vertebral bodies), modeling defects of the hands and feet, or flame-shaped lucencies of hands and feet Bridging of sella turcica, vertebral abnormalities (hemivertebrae, fusion or elongation of vertebral bodies), modeling defects of the hands and feet Skeletal malformations (vertebral, short 4th metacarpals, postaxial polydactyly)
(Rib abnormalities listed as major criterion; see above.) (Rib abnormalities listed as major criterion; see above.)Rib abnormalities
Cardiac or ovarian fibromaOvarian fibromaCardiac or ovarian fibromaCardiac or ovarian fibroma
MedulloblastomaMedulloblastomaMedulloblastoma(Medulloblastoma listed as major criterion; see above.)
Congenital malformation: cleft lip and/or palate, polydactyly, cataract, coloboma, microphthalmiaCleft lip or palate, frontal bossing, moderate or severe hypotelorismCleft lip and/or palate, polydactylyCleft lip or palate
Sprengel deformity, marked pectus deformity, marked syndactylySprengel deformity, marked pectus deformity, marked syndactyly
Lymphomesenteric cystsLymphomesenteric cysts
Eye anomaly: cataract, coloboma, microphthalmiaOcular abnormalities (strabismus, hypertelorism, Congenital cataracts, coloboma)

BCC = basal cell carcinoma.

aTwo major criteria or one major and two minor criteria needed to meet the requirements for a BCNS diagnosis.[49-51]

bDiagnosis is based on one major criterion with molecular diagnosis, two major criteria without molecular diagnosis, or one major and two minor criteria without molecular diagnosis.[52]

From: Genetics of Skin Cancer (PDQ®)

Cover of PDQ Cancer Information Summaries
PDQ Cancer Information Summaries [Internet].
Bethesda (MD): National Cancer Institute (US); 2002-.

NCBI Bookshelf. A service of the National Library of Medicine, National Institutes of Health.