Clinical Description
The spectrum of FARS2 deficiency ranges between two phenotypes: infantile-onset disease characterized by epileptic encephalopathy with lactic acidosis and poor prognosis (70% of affected individuals) and later-onset spastic paraplegia (30% of affected individuals) associated with less severe neurologic manifestations and longer survival.
The findings in the 37 individuals with FARS2 deficiency reported to date are summarized in Table 2 [Elo et al 2012, Shamseldin et al 2012, Almalki et al 2014, Vernon et al 2015, de Kovel et al 2016, Raviglione et al 2016, Walker et al 2016, Yang et al 2016, Cho et al 2017, Vantroys et al 2017, Almannai et al 2018, Sahai et al 2018].
Table 2.
Clinical, Neuroimaging, and Metabolic Findings in FARS2 Deficiency
View in own window
| Infantile Onset | Later Onset |
---|
Number of families
| 19 | 6 |
Number of individuals
| 26 | 11 |
Age at presentation
| Birth-6 mos (median 35 days; mean 62 days) | 6 mos-5 yrs (median 2 yrs; mean 2.1 yrs) |
Outcome
| Alive | 8/23 (age range: 4 mos-3.5 yrs; median 1.6 yrs; mean 1.8 yrs) | 11/11 (age range: 5.5-41 yrs; median 17 yrs; mean 20 yrs) 1 |
Deceased | 15/23 (age range 2 days-15 yrs; median 4 mos; mean 20 mos) | 0/11 |
Neurologic manifestations
| DD/ID | 24/24 | 6/11 |
Truncal hypotonia | 16/19 | 2/9 |
Spasticity | 11/19 | 10/10 (spastic paraplegia) |
Seizures | 24/25 | 3/11 |
Neuroimaging
| MRI: brain atrophy | 15/19 | 2/11 |
MRI: thin corpus callosum | 12/19 | 0/11 |
MRI: hyperintensity of dentate nuclei | 4/19 | 1/11 |
MRS: ↑ lactate peak | 8/11 | NA |
Liver
| Enlarged | 5/19 | 0/11 |
↑ transaminases | 14/19 | 0/11 |
↑ GGT 2 | 8/8 | NA |
Growth
| Failure to thrive | 9/17 | 0/8 |
Microcephaly | 14/18 | 0/7 |
Metabolic
| Lactic acidosis | 21/22 | 3/10 |
↑ CSF lactate | 7/7 | 2/3 |
↑ plasma alanine | 13/17 | 4/6 |
ETC enzyme activity
| Low complex I activity | 3/7 | 1/2 |
Low complex IV activity | 4/7 | 1/2 |
Normal activity | 2/7 | 0/2 |
CSF = cerebrospinal fluid; DD = developmental delay; ETC = electron transport chain; GGT = gamma-glutamyl transferase; ID = intellectual disability; MRI = magnetic resonance imaging; MRS = magnetic resonance spectroscopy
- 1.
One individual who had hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy was not included in age-of-onset calculations. For another individual (who had seizures with a normal EEG following vaccination at age 2 months), age of onset was considered to be 3 years (the age at which he was evaluated for developmental delay [Vernon et al 2015].
- 2.
Elevations up to 1,700 U/L were observed.
Infantile-Onset Epileptic Mitochondrial Encephalopathy
Seizures. Seizures were the most common presenting manifestation. Of note, the only infant who did not have seizures was a premature infant who died at age two days.
Seizures tend to be focal with associated facial or eye twitching and myoclonic jerks of the extremities. Other types of seizures include generalized tonic-clonic, infantile spasms, and epilepsia partialis continua. Seizures are difficult to control and may progress quickly at an early age to intractable seizures with frequent status epilepticus. EEG usually shows multifocal epileptic discharges. A few children had hypsarrhythmia.
Developmental delay. All children had developmental delays affecting all domains. Most did not develop expressive language and were not able to walk. Regression was noted in a few individuals after the onset of seizures.
Variable degree of truncal hypotonia, observed early in the course of the disease, is usually associated with appendicular hypertonia and long tract signs.
Several children with the infantile-onset phenotype developed central visual impairment, usually with normal fundoscopic examination (i.e., without optic atrophy or retinal changes). One child was reported to have coarse retinal pigmentation [Elo et al 2012].
Growth. Failure to thrive reflects the often observed feeding and swallowing difficulties. Microcephaly, which is of postnatal onset, results from diffuse cerebral atrophy that develops later in the disease course.
Liver disease. There was no significant elevation in total and direct bilirubin to suggest cholestasis. Liver involvement of unknown cause manifested as enlarged liver in some individuals. In one child, liver biopsy showed enlarged hepatocytes and increased amounts of glycogen and lysosomal iron and copper. The neuropathologic brain findings of this child met diagnostic criteria for Alpers-Huttenlocher disease [Elo et al 2012] (see also POLG-Related Disorders).
Of note: Although some children were treated with valproic acid (which can induce liver failure in persons with mitochondrial disorders) [Krähenbühl et al 2000], none had evidence of liver dysfunction or worsening of existing liver disease [Elo et al 2012, Walker et al 2016, Cho et al 2017].
Less frequently reported manifestations include the following:
Prognosis. More than half of the reported children with the infantile-onset phenotype died early. Causes of death included uncontrolled seizures and secondary infections. Several children with profound developmental delay and uncontrolled seizures died shortly after the decision was made to provide palliative care only.
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
It is difficult to establish a genotype-phenotype correlation in FARS2 deficiency given the limited number of affected individuals and the complication of compound heterozygosity in such studies.
All 14 individuals homozygous for the most commonly reported variant, p.Tyr144Cys, had the infantile-onset phenotype (see Table 9).
Although the number of affected individuals reported to date is small, the infantile-onset and later-onset phenotypes have not shared the same genotypes.
Nomenclature
FARS2-related infantile-onset epileptic mitochondrial encephalopathy may also be referred to as combined oxidative phosphorylation deficiency 14 or phenylalanyl aminoacyl tRNA synthetase deficiency.
FARS2-related later-onset spastic paraplegia may also be referred to as autosomal recessive spastic paraplegia 77 (SPG77).
Prevalence
FARS2 deficiency is rare; the exact prevalence is unknown. To date, 37 affected individuals from 25 families have been reported.
The 25 families belong to different ethnic groups.
Eleven families (all with children with the infantile-onset phenotype) were Arabs, ten from Saudi Arabia and one from Iraq. In all but two families, the parents were consanguineous.
Other affected populations include Asian, European, North American, Ashkenazi Jewish, and Hispanic.