The term pseudohypoparathyroidism (PHP) refers to disorders with hypocalcemia and hyperphosphatemia (which are typical of hypoparathyroidism) that result from end-organ resistance to ‒ rather than deficiency of ‒ parathyroid hormone (PTH).
Pseudohypoparathyroidism Ia (PHP-Ia) and PHP-Ic
PHP-Ia and PHP-Ic have a similar phenotype and are distinguished only by ex vivo assays of Gsα protein function that are based on hormone receptor activation of Gsα; in these assays Gsα activity is reduced by approximately 50% in PHP-Ia and normal in PHP-Ic (Table 2).
Endocrine. The clinical phenotype consists of metabolic resistance to multiple endocrine hormones including parathyroid hormone (PTH), thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH), growth hormone-releasing hormone (GHRH), calcitonin, and often gonadotropins [Levine 2012]. The most common endocrinopathies are biochemical hypoparathyroidism, primary hypothyroidism (without goiter), and growth hormone deficiency (demonstrated in 50%-70% of affected individuals) [de Sanctis et al 2007]. Obesity, due to decreased resting energy expenditure [Roizen et al 2016], appears to result from impaired Gsα-coupled signaling in imprinted regions of the hypothalamus (which, based on mouse studies, is likely to be in the dorsomedial hypothalamus) [Chen et al 2017].
The development of the endocrine features occurs over time. The earliest manifestation of hormone resistance is usually mild hypothyroidism, which is often discovered during newborn screening as an elevated TSH with normal serum levels of thyroid hormones. The average age at diagnosis of PHP-Ia is around age seven years, when PTH resistance and hypocalcemia are recognized; however, individuals with milder manifestations may not be diagnosed until the third decade of life [Linglart et al 2013, Turan & Bastepe 2015].
TSH resistance is variable and may manifest as congenital hypothyroidism; however, TSH may be elevated in individuals who are euthyroid, or only after formal TRH stimulation testing. Serum levels of thyroid hormone are usually normal or only mildly depressed.
PTH resistance. Although random PTH levels are often elevated in PHP-Ia, hypocalcemia may fluctuate and may not become clinically significant until later childhood. Hyperphosphatemia usually precedes hypocalcemia. Some individuals remain eucalcemic.
Occasionally, early PTH resistance is associated with hypercalcemia rather than hypocalcemia. Presumably, in these individuals the kidney retains the ability to increase production of 1,25(OH)2D, the active form of vitamin D, in response to the elevated levels of circulating PTH that result from decreased ability to excrete urinary phosphate [MA Levine, personal observation].
As in PTH-deficient hypoparathyroidism, protracted hypocalcemia and hyperphosphatemia lead to ectopic calcification, particularly in the brain at the grey-white cerebral intersection and the basal ganglia and ocular lenses, manifesting as posterior subcapsular cataracts.
Unrecognized hypocalcemia may present with tetany, seizures, or laryngeal spasm; seizures appear to be more common, independent of hypocalcemia [
Fitch 1982]. Cataracts can also be seen in the setting of prolonged hypocalcemia.
Gonadotropin
resistance may result in delayed puberty and incomplete development of secondary sex characteristics, menstrual irregularities, or reduced fertility.
Sleep apnea is also common (45% of individuals), but is only partly explained by obesity, as individuals with PHP-Ia have a fourfold increased risk for sleep apnea compared to similarly obese individuals. This increase may be due to hypotonia as well as the effects of Gsα inactivation on the normal sleep cycle [Landreth et al 2015].
Musculoskeletal. At birth growth parameters are usually normal, but can be below normal [Wilson 2006]; however, neonates may then present with congenital hypothyroidism or ectopic ossifications.
Linear growth may initially be normal or advanced due to obesity; bone age is frequently advanced beyond chronologic age [Fitch 1982]. Linear growth slows soon after early childhood and prematurely ceases in early puberty, leading to height below the third percentile in the majority of adults [Fitch 1982, Wilson 2006] primarily due to premature closure of epiphyseal growth plates; however, GH deficiency may also be a contributing factor.
Affected individuals display clinical features of Albright hereditary osteodystrophy (AHO) comprising a round face, short stature, brachydactyly/brachymetacarpia, and heterotopic ossification of the dermis and subcutaneous tissues. Macrocephaly relative to height is typical: 40% have a head circumference above the 90th percentile [Fitch 1982, Wilson 2006].
The most common musculoskeletal feature is brachydactyly; brachydactyly type E is manifest as shortened metacarpals (particularly 4th and 5th) and metatarsals (particularly 3rd and 4th) plus brachydactyly type D, manifest as shortening of the distal phalanx of the thumb.
Even in the absence of brachymetacarpia, individuals with AHO usually have brachydactyly type D, a shortened distal thumb phalanx and short, broad thumbnails, associated radiographically with cone-shaped epiphyses [Fitch 1982].
Brachydactyly may lead to carpal tunnel syndrome with symptomatic paresthesia, which may be confused with the symptoms of hypocalcemia [Joseph et al 2011].
Other reported musculoskeletal features include craniosynostosis, hyperostosis of the cranial vault, absence of normal caudal widening of the lumbar interpedicular distances (associated with spinal stenosis), ossification of paravertebral ligaments, shortened distal ulnas, bowing of the tibia and radius, small capital femoral epiphyses, coxa vara, coxa valga, increased prevalence of bony exostoses, and carpal tunnel syndrome [Wilson & Hall 2002, van Lindert et al 2008, Joseph et al 2011].
Skin. Ectopic ossifications (also known as osteoma cutis) are true heterotopic intramembraneous bone which occur in 60%-70% of affected individuals, independent of calcium, phosphate, or PTH levels [Prendiville et al 1992].
Ectopic ossifications are most commonly cutaneous, either within subdermal fat or in the dermis. They are located most commonly in the scalp and extremities (particularly the periarticular areas of the hands and feet). These lesions may be very small and asymptomatic, or painful; occasionally lesions can extrude a chalky material. Removal of ectopic ossifications does not result in progression or exacerbation although they may recur if removal is incomplete [Fitch 1982, Prendiville et al 1992, Wilson 2006].
Other areas of ectopic ossification include the sclera and choroid of the eye and cardiac ventricular septum. Visceral involvement is rare [Fitch 1982].
Dental changes such as enamel hypoplasia, widened root canals, shortened roots with open apices, thickened laminar dura, and delayed dental eruption have been noted in more than 30% of affected individuals, often with impacted second molars [Ritchie 1965].
Mild-to-moderate intellectual disability is seen in up to 79% of affected individuals [Mouallem et al 2008].