Clinical Description
A more or less distinctive phenotype is characteristic of alpha-thalassemia X-linked intellectual disability (ATR-X) syndrome. Craniofacial, genital, and developmental manifestations are prominent among the most severely affected individuals [Gibbons et al 1995b, Badens et al 2006a, Stevenson et al 2012].
As additional individuals/families have been evaluated using molecular genetic testing, the range of phenotypic variability has broadened, particularly on the mild end of the spectrum. Affected males may have mild, moderate, or profound intellectual disability (ID), even within the same family. Adults in the family described by Yntema et al [2002] appeared to have nonsyndromic X-linked ID (XLID), although childhood photographs showed evidence of facial hypotonia. Basehore et al [2015] reported 25 affected males in five families with the p.Arg37Ter variant who had variable but overall milder phenotypes (see Genotype-Phenotype Correlations).
Table 2.
Selected Features of Alpha-thalassemia X-linked Intellectual Disability Syndrome
View in own window
Feature | % of Persons with Feature | Comments |
---|
Developmental delay | 100% | A minority never speak or have meaningful speech. |
Intellectual disability | 100% | Variable severity, from mild to profound |
Characteristic facies
| 90% | Usually present from birth, but may persist or become less distinctive in adult life. W/age, face may also coarsen w/open mouth, spaced teeth, & prominent lips. |
Microcephaly | 75%-85% | Usually present at birth; head size of those w/out microcephaly usually in lower centiles |
Short stature | 60%-70% | Usually present at birth |
Gastrointestinal dysfunction | 70%-80% | A major morbidity; incl: early feeding difficulty, vomiting, reflux, abdominal distention, obstruction, pain, & constipation |
Genital anomalies | 70%-80% | Wide range, from minimal hypospadias or undescended testes to normal-appearing female external genitalia |
Neurologic | Hypotonia | 80%-90% | Contributes to facial phenotype |
Seizures | 30%-40% |
Developmental Impairment / Intellectual Disability
Severe developmental impairment and intellectual disability are the most important clinical manifestations. From the outset, developmental milestones are globally and markedly delayed. Speech and ambulation occur late in childhood. Some affected individuals never walk independently or develop significant speech.
Growth Impairment
Growth impairment with microcephaly and short stature occurs in most individuals with ATR-X syndrome and is often present at birth. Stature is typically short (>2 SD below the mean in 67% of individuals using standard growth charts; syndrome-specific growth charts are not available). Growth above average is exceptional.
Gastrointestinal Manifestations
Gastrointestinal manifestations, present in the majority of individuals, contribute significantly to morbidity. Approximately three fourths have gastroesophageal reflux and one third have chronic constipation. Gastric pseudo-obstruction can result from abnormal suspension of the stomach and constipation can result from colon hypoganglionosis [Martucciello et al 2006]. Aspiration, presumably related to gastroesophageal reflux, has been a fatal complication in some.
Genital Anomalies
Genital anomalies are often minor, including first-degree hypospadias, undescended testes, and underdevelopment of the scrotum. Although all individuals with ATR-X syndrome have a normal 46,XY karyotype, gonadal dysgenesis resulting in inadequate testosterone production can cause more severe defects that can include second- and third-degree hypospadias, small penis, ambiguous genitalia, or even normal-appearing female external genitalia. Although all individuals with ATR-X syndrome have a normal 46,XY karyotype, occasionally gonadal dysgenesis results in inadequate testosterone production and ambiguous genitalia. Although the spectrum of possible genital anomalies in ATR-X syndrome is broad, the type of genital anomaly appears to be consistent within a family.
Hypotonia
Hypotonia, a hallmark of ATR-X syndrome, contributes to the facial manifestations, drooling, developmental delay, and possibly to the gastrointestinal manifestations.
Other
The neurobehavioral phenotype has not been extensively delineated; however, most individuals appear affable, but some are emotionally labile with tantrums and bouts of prolonged crying or laughing.
Minor skeletal anomalies (brachydactyly, clinodactyly, tapered digits, joint contractures, pectus carinatum, kyphosis, scoliosis, dimples over the lower spine, varus and valgus foot deformation, and pes planus) occur, but do not contribute significantly to morbidity.
Major malformations are not common, but ocular coloboma, cleft palate, cardiac defects, inguinal hernia, heterotaxy, and asplenia [Leahy et al 2005] have been reported.
Although predisposition to tumor development has not been confirmed in individuals with germline ATRX pathogenic variants, four children with ATR-X syndrome have developed osteosarcoma [Ji et al 2017, Masliah-Planchon et al 2018], a finding that contrasts with the well-recognized tumor association of somatic ATRX pathogenic variants (see Cancer and Benign Tumors). Masliah-Planchon et al [2018] provide clinical, histologic, and genetic data supporting the possibility of tumor predisposition associated with germline ATRX pathogenic variants in their report of three instances of osteosarcoma in two males:
One individual with two metachronous osteosarcomas, the first (of the tibia) diagnosed and successfully treated at age nine years, and the second (of the humerus) diagnosed and successfully treated ten years later at age 20 years
One child, diagnosed with osteosarcoma of the femur with pulmonary nodules at age four years, who succumbed 18 months later
Heterozygous Females
Heterozygous females rarely show clinical manifestations. Typically, carrier females have marked skewing of X-chromosome inactivation (>90:10) with preferential inactivation of the X chromosome with the ATRX pathogenic variant. Rare exceptions have been reported, including the following:
Moderate ID without other phenotypic features of ATR-X syndrome in a female carrier with random X-chromosome inactivation [
Wada et al 2005]
A girl conceived by in vitro fertilization (IVF) who had craniofacial features, growth restriction, and developmental impairment typical of ATR-X syndrome [
Badens et al 2006b]. Leukocyte studies showed marked skewing of X-chromosome inactivation with her pathogenic variant-bearing X chromosome being the active X chromosome. The role of IVF in this unique case of female expression is not known.
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
Pathogenic variants that affect the ATRX zinc finger domain produce severe psychomotor impairment and urogenital anomalies, whereas pathogenic variants in the helicase domains cause milder phenotypes [Badens et al 2006a].
More severe genital anomalies occur with variants in the plant homeodomain-like domain.
A nonsense variant in exon 2 (p.Arg37Ter) appears to be a common pathogenic variant that results in an overall milder phenotype [Basehore et al 2015] (see Table 7).
Nomenclature
"Alpha-thalassemia X-linked intellectual disability syndrome" and "ATR-X syndrome" are the preferred designations for this disorder.
ATRX pathogenic variants have been found in several named XLID syndromes (Carpenter-Waziri syndrome, Holmes-Gang syndrome, Chudley-Lowry syndrome, XLID-arch fingerprints – hypotonia), in XLID with spastic paraplegia, in XLID with epilepsy, and in nonsyndromic XLID [Lossi et al 1999, Stevenson 2000, Stevenson et al 2000, Yntema et al 2002, Stevenson et al 2012]. These entities should be considered to be in the phenotypic spectrum of ATR-X syndrome; there are no compelling reasons to maintain the syndromic names.
Note: A family considered to have Juberg-Marsidi syndrome had an ATRX pathogenic variant [Villard et al 1996]. Subsequently, the original family reported with Juberg-Marsidi syndrome was found to have a HUWE1 pathogenic variant, indicating that the family studied by Villard et al [1996] represented a misdiagnosis [Friez et al 2016].
Although two families considered to have Smith-Fineman-Myers syndrome have ATRX pathogenic variants, the original family with Smith-Fineman-Myers has not been restudied. Hence, the relationship of ATR-X syndrome and Smith-Fineman-Myers syndrome is unclear [Villard et al 1999a, Li et al 2020].