Clinical Description
Pyruvate carboxylase (PC) deficiency is characterized in most affected individuals by failure to gain weight and/or linear growth failure, developmental delay, epilepsy, and metabolic acidosis. Historically, three phenotypes of PC deficiency (types A, B, and C) have been recognized based on clinical presentation (see GeneReview Scope).
Type A (infantile form). Most affected children die in infancy or early childhood. Brain anomalies can be noted.
Type B (severe neonatal form). Affected infants have hepatomegaly, pyramidal tract signs, abnormal movements, brain abnormalities, and die by eight months of life.
Type C (intermittent/attenuated form). Affected individuals have relatively normal or mildly delayed neurologic development, motor and/or gait abnormalities, episodic seizure, and episodic movement disorders.
These phenotypes likely represent a continuum ranging from most severe (type B) to least severe (type C) rather than distinct subtypes.
Approximately 75 individuals with PC deficiency have been reported to date, with most being either type A or type B; approximately 15 individuals have been reported with type C [Habarou et al 2014, Mangla et al 2017, Almomen et al 2018, Coci et al 2019, Demir Köse et al 2020, Bayat et al 2021, Doğulu et al 2021, Hidalgo et al 2021, Mhanni et al 2021, Sahdev et al 2021, Tao et al 2022, Tsygankova et al 2022, Bernhardt et al 2023, Lasio et al 2023, Maryami et al 2023, Xue 2023]. The following description of the phenotypic features associated with this condition is based on these reports (see Table 3).
Table 3.
Pyruvate Carboxylase Deficiency: Phenotypes by Select Clinical Features
View in own window
Feature | Phenotype |
---|
Type A | Type B | Type C |
---|
Prenatal neurologic presentation 1
| + | + |
−
|
Age of onset
| Birth to age 10 mos | Within 1-3 days of birth | Age 3 mos to 2 yrs |
Development
| Development delay & intellectual disability | Severe developmental delay | Normal or mildly delayed motor &/or speech development & intellectual disability, autism |
Growth
| Poor feeding, vomiting, failure to gain weight, linear growth failure | Poor feeding, vomiting, lethargy, hypothermia | Limited information; may be normal |
Hypotonia
| + | + | May be episodic |
Respiratory
| Respiratory distress/failure, tachypnea, exertional dyspnea | Respiratory distress/failure at birth, tachypnea | Respiratory distress, tachypnea (may be episodic), Kussmaul breathing, exertional dyspnea |
Hepatomegaly
| + | + | + |
Epilepsy
| + | + | Seizure disorder described in 1 person 2 |
Movement disorders
| Pyramidal tract signs, ataxia, choreoathetoid movements, nystagmus | Pyramidal tract signs, high-amplitude tremor, dyskinesia, & abnormal ocular movements | Dystonia, dysarthria, transient hemiparesis, &/or acute transient flaccid paralysis |
Ataxia / choreoathetoid movements
| + | − | May be episodic |
Nystagmus
| + | + | − |
Development
| Severe delay w/marked speech delay if survive long term | Severe delay if survive long term | Normal or mild delay incl motor & speech, depending on frequency of metabolic acidosis |
Life span
| Early infant or early childhood death | Death in neonatal period | Unknown but long-term survival reported |
Habarou et al [2014], Mangla et al [2017], Almomen et al [2018], Coci et al [2019], Demir Köse et al [2020], Bayat et al [2021], Doğulu et al [2021], Hidalgo et al [2021], Mhanni et al [2021], Tao et al [2022], Tsygankova et al [2022], Bernhardt et al [2023], Lasio et al [2023], Maryami et al [2023], Xue [2023]
+ = present; − = not reported
- 1.
Includes brain anomalies in fetuses homozygous for the North American Indigenous population founder variant p.Ala610Thr [Mhanni et al 2021].
- 2.
PC Deficiency Type A
PC deficiency type A is characterized by infantile onset with metabolic acidosis, lactic acidosis, delayed motor development, intellectual disability, failure to gain weight and/or linear growth failure, apathy, hypotonia, pyramidal tract signs, ataxia, chorea-like movements, nystagmus, and seizures.
Episodes of acute vomiting, tachypnea, and lactic acidosis with a compensated metabolic acidosis are usually precipitated by metabolic or infectious stress. Some individuals may require gastrostomy tube placement.
Prognosis. Most affected children die in infancy or early childhood following an acute illness. Development of uncontrolled severe metabolic acidosis during a hospital course with continued deterioration despite hemodialysis can be followed by death [Tao et al 2022]. Survival to early childhood and use of liver transplantation have been reported [Lasio et al 2023]. Some may survive to teenage years or young adulthood, and manifest varying degrees of cognitive impairment [Mangla et al 2017, Bayat et al 2021, Lasio et al 2023].
PC Deficiency Type B
PC deficiency type B is characterized by affected neonates and infants presenting with hypothermia (neonates), lethargy, respiratory distress/failure, vomiting, severe lactic acidosis, and hyperammonemia; presenting individuals are likely to develop hypoglycemia. Some affected individuals may require gastrostomy tube placement. Other features include hepatomegaly (or hepatosplenomegaly), epilepsy, and neurologic findings, including hypotonia, pyramidal tract signs, and abnormal movements (including high-amplitude tremor and dyskinesia). Motor development is severely delayed and affected infants have marked developmental delay.
Prognosis. Most affected neonates/infants die within the neonatal period or within the first eight months of life [Breen et al 2014, Mochel 2017, Lasio et al 2023]. Unrecoverable renal tubular acidosis despite massive bicarbonate replacement or multiorgan (liver) failure have been causes of death [Demir Köse et al 2020]. Death due to respiratory and hepatic failure with hepatomegaly and histopathologic findings of balloon dystrophy of hepatocytes was reported [Tsygankova et al 2022]. An individual who underwent liver transplantation at age 6.5 months was alive at age 20 years [Lasio et al 2023].
PC Deficiency Type C
In the approximately 15 individuals with PC deficiency type C reported to date, development has ranged from relatively normal (e.g., individuals who walk independently and have some speech and slight cognitive delays) to others with mild developmental delays involving motor skills, speech, and/or cognition; other individuals have had speech delay, a broad-based toe-walking or unsteady gait, and autism spectrum disorder with stereotypic movements (hand flapping) with an otherwise normal neurologic examination [Almomen et al 2018, Coci et al 2019, Doğulu et al 2021, Tsygankova et al 2022, Bernhardt et al 2023, Lasio et al 2023].
Other findings reported in some individuals have included exertional dyspnea, seizures, and episodic metabolic acidosis. In one report, the initial clinical presentation mimicked diabetic ketoacidosis [Doğulu et al 2021]. Acute transient flaccid paralysis with ketoacidosis was reported in a previously healthy and developmentally normal 11-month-old girl [Almomen et al 2018].
Prognosis. Life span is unknown, but survival into adulthood has been reported [Sahdev et al 2021].
Other
Neuroimaging findings. Several largely nonspecific brain abnormalities have been reported.
Genotype-Phenotype Correlations
The pathogenic variant p.Ala610Thr is a founder variant in the native North American Ojibwa, Cree, and Mi'kmaq tribes of the Algonquin-speaking peoples in northwestern Ontario and northeastern Manitoba, Canada [Haworth et al 1991, Carbone et al 1998]. In all 14 affected individuals of Ojibwa and Cree origin, homozygous p.Ala610Thr pathogenic variants were identified. Brain anomalies were identified at age ten days, suggesting that these changes were present in utero [Mhanni et al 2021].
Classes of pathogenic variants. Disease severity has been loosely correlated with the class of PC pathogenic variant. Pathogenic missense and intronic variants are more often associated with PC deficiency types A and C, whereas truncating or nonsense variants are more often associated with PC deficiency type B [Coci et al 2019, Demir Köse et al 2020, Tsygankova et al 2022, Lasio et al 2023]. Whether disease-modifying factors for specific PC pathogenic variants exist is not known.
Of note, in general, there is no significant correlation between the clinical phenotype and level of fibroblast- or lymphocyte-based residual PC enzyme activity, although no detectable or low PC activity (<2% of unaffected control mean) is more often associated with PC deficiency type B [Ostergaard et al 2013, Coci et al 2019, Lasio et al 2023].
Prevalence
About 75 individuals with PC deficiency have been reported, with most being either type A or type B. Because type C may be under reported, the prevalence of PC deficiency in most populations may be higher.
In most populations, the birth incidence of PC deficiency is considered low (1 in 250,000), but prospective studies evaluating the incidence in newborns in most populations have not been completed.
In the native North American Ojibwa, Cree, and Mi'kmaq tribes of the Algonquin-speaking peoples in northwestern Ontario and northeastern Manitoba, Canada, the carrier frequency of the founder variant p.Ala610Thr may be as high as 1 in 10 [Haworth et al 1991, Carbone et al 1998].